Made In New York Pizza
4.6 (1,324)restaurant
4.6 (1,324)An Upper West Side spot for classic NYC slices and deep-dish pies, complete with street-side tables and late-night hours.
Description
Located on Amsterdam Avenue, this clean counter spot keeps things moving with efficient service and a wide lineup of toppings, from pepperoni and sausage to generous veggie options. While the space has a few tables, the setup means most patrons treat it as a take-away operation. Ordering is especially straightforward thanks to a bilingual staff speaking English and Spanish. It is a reliable, inexpensive neighborhood fallback for a quick single slice or a full square pie.
Selected reviews
Also featured in
After Hours Food Finds on the Upper West SideEvening bites · Mixed budgets · Manhattan tables
Filipino-Thai Plates and Ramen on Amsterdam AveFilipino-Thai feasts · Bologna and ramen · Upper West Side
Sourdough Pizza Slices With Mushroom And Pepperoni EdgeCreative toppings · Counter service · Wall Street
Thin Chewy Brick Oven Pies with Parm SubsPizza Counter · Family Run Kitchen · 4973 Broadway
4 Upper West Side Restaurants On Amsterdam Avenue For Brunch, Pizza And SushiA longtime brunch spot, a pizza shop, a neighborhood restaurant and a Japanese dining room side by side.
Manhattan Pizza and Bagels Served Around the Clock on St MarksCounter service · Sandwiches and calzones · Sidewalk tables
Financial District Pizza Slices on Trinity PlaceNew York slices · Trinity Place · Park across street
East Harlem Coal Fired Pizza on First Avenue, NYCItalian dining · Cash only takeout · 2287 1st Ave
Old School Pizzeria With Classic Slices, Brick WallsWhole pies · 2671 Broadway · Opens at noon
Thin Crust Pizza and Chilean Empanadas Dating Back to 1978Counter served slices · 303 Amsterdam Avenue · Upper West Side