Sammy's Fish Box
A bustling City Island spot serving massive portions of fresh seafood in a colorful, stained-glass-lit dining room.
- Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 01:00 (+1)
- 41 City Island Ave
- 4.3 (10888 reviews)
Description
Inside, the dining room features booth seating and a massive menu with an extensive selection of seafood. The kitchen tends to prepare dishes lightly seasoned, leaving diners to adjust flavor to taste at the table. While the family-sized portions make it a popular choice for group dining, visitors note that service speed and food consistency can vary.