Sammy's Fish Box
4.3 (10,888)restaurant
4.3 (10,888)A bustling City Island spot serving massive portions of fresh seafood in a colorful, stained-glass-lit dining room.
Description
Inside, the dining room features booth seating and a massive menu with an extensive selection of seafood. The kitchen tends to prepare dishes lightly seasoned, leaving diners to adjust flavor to taste at the table. While the family-sized portions make it a popular choice for group dining, visitors note that service speed and food consistency can vary.
Selected reviews
Also featured in
City Island Seafood Dining Offers Massive PortionsGroup dining · Booth seating · City Island Avenue
Brick-Oven Pizza and Seafood After Dark24-hour option · Latin American dishes
Fried Seafood Baskets with Chicken on Grand ConcourseQuick takeout · Bronx storefront · Rice sides
A Seafood Escape to City Island, Without Leaving NYC591 City Island Ave · Sea Shore open 12 PM–11 PM daily · about 60–90 min from Manhattan
The Maritime Museum at Fort Schuyler, Then Fried Seafood at Johnny's ReefHidden fort museum · SUNY Maritime campus · Waterfront seafood
Casual Cafeteria Dining Along the Bronx WaterfrontSeafood counter · City Island setting · Cash only
Fried Seafood Beside a Longstanding Waterfront Picnic SpotCafeteria service · Indoor outdoor seating · City Island
Grab New York Slices and Foil Tray Parm on City IslandSesame seed burgers · Baked stuffed peppers · Bronx counter