Garlic New York Pizza Bar

4.3 (616)restaurant

$4.80 – $40.74
629 2nd Ave

A relaxed spot serving creative slices and Italian classics, complete with a cozy bar and a quiet backyard patio.

Order now

Description

Pizzas here start with a hand-tossed, additive-free Italian semolina crust topped with hand-crushed tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella from a local dairy. While the counter features a variety of quick slices—including a grandma eggplant pizza and a chicken Caesar slice with finely chopped lettuce—the kitchen also serves generous portions of non-pizza dishes like Bolognese sauce. It is a straightforward, clean setup where the quick service and backyard seating offer a welcome break from the street noise.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Late weekend hoursOffers delivery

Also featured in

Seven Days Chasing Pizza Counters Beyond East VillageBagel breakfasts · Manhattan detours · 8 stopsThin Crispy Pizza Starts with 72 Hours of LeaveningStone baked slices · Sesame hoagie heros · 4.7 ratingScratch Made Pizza and Cauliflower Crusts in East HarlemVegetarian dishes · Espresso drinks · Outdoor seatingCrispy Pizza Crust with a Chewy Bite on BroadwaySlice stop · Online ordering · Manhattan pizzeriaNYC Slices and Garlic Knots with Room to SitPizza stop · Thin crust · Seventh AvenueCrispy New York Slices From a Tiny Manhattan CounterPizza stop · 154 Church StreetBrooklyn Pizza With Sesame Crust and Spicy SquaresVodka Slice · Avenue O · 4.8 From 121Cheese Slices, Specialty Pies, and Calzones on 23rdPizza shop · 5.0 rating · Manhattan locationMurray Hill Pizza With Calzones and WingsVodka slices · Indoor seatingFinancial District Pizza Slices on Trinity PlaceNew York slices · Trinity Place · Park across streetGramercy Pizza Slices Until 4 AM on WeekendsCasual dining · Italian classicsGluten Free Pizza Slices on the Upper East SideSlice counter · Gluten free options · York AvenueWilliamsburg Neapolitan Pies With a Full BarFull service bar · Brooklyn dining · Lava cakeChicago Deep Dish Pizza in Manhattan on MacDougal StreetPizza restaurant · Private events · Manhattan diningTheater District Pizza Slices Open Late at Famous PopsSpecialty Pies · Beer Selection · Theater DistrictMidtown Pizza Slices Reheated Extra Crispy on RequestCounter dining · Standing room · Pasta availableStaten Island Crispy Pizza Slices and Classic HeroesItalian heroes · Opens daily · Seated diningMeatpacking Neapolitan Pizza Across From the WhitneyPersonal pizza · Patio seating · 4.7 ratingLate-Night Halal Pizza on the Lower East Side Until 3 AMCounter bites · 61 Delancey Street · Daily serviceCrispy Slices and Fresh Sandwiches Near Port AuthorityCounter service · Custom salads · 717 8th Ave

Ask Karpo for more information.