Scratch Made Pizza and Cauliflower Crusts in East Harlem
Pair a pie with house baked desserts, or explore Mexican dishes and calzones at this neighborhood cafe.
🍽️ Beyond The Pie
Healthy Choice Pizza and Cafe stretches a pizza stop into a full meal at 18 E 116th St in East Harlem. The kitchen makes its dough from scratch, with gluten free and cauliflower crusts among the options. Sauces and toppings are prepared from scratch too, giving you several ways to build an order around the pie.
Bring a wider appetite and look beyond the pizza. Mexican dishes sit alongside burgers, pasta, calzones and vegetarian choices. You can settle into indoor or outdoor seating and leave space for house baked desserts, espresso, ice cream or cakes.
The staff also accommodates custom requests, including off menu shakes or fresh fruit. Ask about those options while putting together your order. The cafe opens daily from 7 AM to midnight, leaving a long window for a meal on East 116th Street and a chance to linger over something sweet afterward.
