San Francisco is seven miles by seven miles, which means almost any pizzeria in the city is theoretically close to almost anywhere. It is also one of the steepest cities in the world and one of the coldest American cities in summer, which means the fifteen-minute trip home is a genuine variable rather than a rounding error. Some pizza arrives at your kitchen table in the condition it left the oven. Some of it does not, and the difference is predictable.
Which pizza survives the trip depends on the style, the hill and the fog. Ask Karpo which pizzeria near you is worth collecting from tonight.
What travels and what does not
Thin, wet, fast-baked pizza is the worst traveller there is. A Neapolitan pie with a soft centre and torn mozzarella is engineered to be eaten within about ninety seconds of leaving the oven, and by the time it has been boxed, carried and climbed a hill it has steamed itself into something else. This is not a criticism of the pizza; it is the wrong tool for the journey.
What travels well is anything with a firmer, drier base and a lower moisture load: New York-style rounds baked in a deck oven, especially if asked for well done; Sicilian and grandma squares baked in a pan, which have enough structure to be indifferent to a bit of steam; Detroit-style pan pizza, where the caramelised cheese edge holds the whole thing together; and the sourdough-crust pizzas that several San Francisco pizzerias make, which have a stiffer crumb by construction.
The San Francisco variables
Three local conditions change the calculation. The hills, first: a map distance of a mile can involve a two-hundred-metre climb, and a courier or a cyclist will route around gradient rather than through it, so the actual journey is longer than it looks. The fog, second: a summer evening in the Richmond or the Sunset can be ten degrees colder than the same evening in the Mission, and a pizza crossing the city west loses heat far faster than one crossing it east.
The third is density, which works in your favour. In most of San Francisco there is a competent pizzeria within a fifteen-minute walk, and collecting it yourself removes both the fee and the twenty minutes the box spends waiting for a courier. In a city this compact, collection is very often faster than the delivery estimate.
Where the neighbourhood pizza is
North Beach is the historic centre of Italian San Francisco and still has the highest concentration of long-established pizzerias, mostly in the blocks around Columbus Avenue. The Mission and Bernal Heights have the strongest new-generation pizza, including several of the sourdough-crust rooms that have become a genuine local style. The Sunset and the Richmond have the neighbourhood counters — unglamorous, cheap, built for collection — and the Excelsior and Portola have more of the same at lower prices.
The city also has a real Detroit-style and pan-pizza scene, disproportionately in SoMa and the Mission, which is worth knowing precisely because those styles are the best travellers in the city. If you are eating at home rather than out, that is where to look first.
How to order for the journey
Ask for it well done. This is the single most effective thing you can do to a pizza that has to travel, and every deck-oven shop in the city understands the request. A slightly firmer base tolerates fifteen minutes in a box in a way a pale one does not. Ask for it uncut if you are going more than ten minutes — an uncut pie traps far less steam and can be cut at home.
Ask them to vent the box, or open a corner yourself for the first minute, which lets the initial burst of steam out before it condenses onto the crust. Carry it flat rather than tilted; a box on its side redistributes the cheese in a way that cannot be undone. And if you are cycling, a flat rack or a rigid box is worth more than any insulation, because the pizza's enemy on a fifteen-minute ride is steam rather than cold.
The other thing worth planning around is timing. San Francisco pizzerias are busiest between six-thirty and eight, and a collection order placed at seven on a Friday will be quoted forty-five minutes because the oven has a queue. The same order at five-thirty or after nine is ready in fifteen. Since you are collecting anyway, shifting the pick-up an hour either side of the peak is worth more than choosing a closer shop.
Reviving it at home
If the pizza does arrive soft, a dry pan on the hob over a medium heat for three or four minutes with a lid on for the last minute is the fastest fix — the base re-crisps against the pan while the cheese re-melts under the lid. An oven at a high temperature on a preheated tray works too and is better for a whole pie. A microwave is the one thing that will make it permanently worse.
This is worth knowing in San Francisco specifically because the temperature drop on a foggy evening is enough to firm up cheese on even a short journey, and a pizza that looks ruined at the door is usually four minutes from being good again.
Practical notes
Most San Francisco pizzerias take orders directly by phone or through their own site, which is cheaper for you and considerably better for them than a third-party platform. Several add a surcharge to the bill that is printed at the bottom of the menu rather than announced, so check before you tip. Kitchens here close earlier than in most large American cities and last orders are often well before the stated closing time. Bring a bag with a flat bottom if you are collecting. And if you are heading uphill, allow more time than the map suggests — it is always longer than it looks.
Tags: #SanFrancisco #SFFood #Pizza #PizzaNearMe #NorthBeach #MissionDistrict #BernalHeights #SunsetDistrict #RichmondDistrict #Sourdough #DetroitStyle #Takeout #SFEats #FoodNearMe
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Want to know which pizzerias near you are still baking, whether collection beats the delivery estimate tonight, and how steep the walk back actually is? Ask Karpo before you order.
