Where to Find Handcrafted Pizza in Queens Village

Gaby's Pizza on 204-23 Hillside Avenue is the family-run Queens Village pizza room that has been working from recipes passed down through the family since the mid-1960s, preparing each dish by hand from selected ingredients.

It is open 11 AM to 10 PM seven days a week, which makes it workable for a late weeknight dinner as well as a weekend table. Expect handcrafted pies with a traditional Italian list alongside them, dine-in seating for a family, and takeout for a night at home, at a $$ price range.

Address: 204-23 Hillside Avenue, Queens Village, Queens
Hours: 11 AM–10 PM, seven days a week
Menu: handcrafted pizza and traditional Italian dishes
Best for: family dinners, comfort food, a neighborhood table
Price: $$
Rating: 4.4 out of 5 from 3,136 reviews
Phone: (718) 740-9716

The pies are the point: hand-stretched dough, a traditional sauce-and-cheese build, and a crust that holds up on the walk home. Starters and pasta come from the same recipes the family has kept going since the mid-1960s, so a table can order a pie each plus one plate for the middle. Nothing here is built as a novelty — this is a neighborhood Italian kitchen rather than a slice-of-the-month counter.

Gaby's keeps the same hours all week, 11 AM to 10 PM, so there is no wrong evening to drive over — the difference is the room. Weekend dinners fill first with families, while a weekday after 8 PM is the quietest window for a table. If you are collecting takeout, call ahead and eat at home rather than waiting by the door through the dinner rush.

Queens Village puts several different dinners within a few kilometres: a Greek and American diner open daily, a Portuguese room with grilled octopus on Jamaica Avenue, and a Queens Chinese takeout on Linden Boulevard. Gaby's is the pizza-and-Italian side of that choice, and further out there are wood-fired Brooklyn pies and a Whitestone Italian kitchen that also does gluten-free crusts.

Where is Gaby's Pizza?
204-23 Hillside Avenue in Queens Village, Queens.

What are the hours?
11 AM–10 PM, seven days a week.

How long has Gaby's been open?
The family has run the kitchen since the mid-1960s.

What is on the menu?
Handcrafted pizza and traditional Italian dishes, prepared by hand from family recipes.

Is it good for families?
Yes. It is tagged family-run and comfort food, with dine-in seating and takeout.

How is Gaby's Pizza rated?
4.4 out of 5 from 3,136 reviews.

Five Queens pages to build a night around Gaby's: a wood-fired Brooklyn pie shop with a sesame white slice and raw dough to take home, a Queens Village diner serving Greek and American plates daily, a Portuguese kitchen with grilled octopus on Jamaica Avenue, a Whitestone Italian restaurant with gluten-free pizza, and a Queens Chinese takeout on Linden Boulevard with sushi options.