Great Kills Pizza With a Charred Thin Crust

Plain pies with charred thin slices and zeppoles made to order in Great Kills.

Save room for the zeppoles.

🍕 A Plain Slice With Char

At 27 Brower Ct in Great Kills, Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria keeps the neighborhood slice straightforward. Thin, crispy pizza with a signature char is the draw here, with a focus on simple preparation rather than elaborate combinations. The kitchen starts with savory dough and balances the sauce and cheese, giving a plain slice the attention it deserves.

The menu extends into classic Italian dishes when the appetite calls for more than a single piece of pizza. Pillowy zeppoles are made to order, an option worth leaving room for alongside the savory part of the meal.

The entire lineup is prepared quickly for pickup or free delivery, keeping a meal from here available away from the shop. The pizzeria is open daily from 11 AM to 10 PM, with the same hours throughout the week for lunch or an evening order on Staten Island.


🍽️ More Staten Island Pizzerias

Ask Karpo for more information.