Nonna's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

4.5 (641)restaurant

27 Brower Ct

This Great Kills spot serves up thin, crispy slices with a signature char alongside pillowy, made-to-order zeppoles.

Get directions

Description

The kitchen focuses on simple, no-gimmick plain slices built on a savory dough with balanced portions of sauce and cheese. The menu extends to classic Italian dishes, with the entire lineup prepped quickly for pickup or free delivery. While local preferences vary regarding the pies' specific style, the appeal lies in straightforward execution that eschews trends for reliable neighborhood standards.


Selected reviews


Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.