La Nostra Pizzeria
An easygoing counter-service spot turning out classic New York slices, vodka pies, and hot Italian staples.
- Mon – Sun, 10:00 – 22:00
- $
- 2146 2nd Ave #3207
- 4.5 (433 reviews)
Description
This East Harlem staple has maintained its local reputation and classic flavor despite changing management over the years. Beyond the standard slice, the kitchen turns out pepperoni pizzas baked into circular rolls and hearty options like the Large Sicilian Pie and Meat Pie. Non-pizza options include Alfredo pasta and chicken parmigiana. Slices and pies are prepared quickly, with options like their 12-inch mini pizzas offering a smaller format.