Johnny's Reef Restaurant
This casual City Island institution has served fresh and fried seafood at waterfront picnic tables for over 60 years.
- Mon – Thu, 11:30 – 22:00; Fri – Sat, 11:30 – 23:30; Sun, 11:30 – 00:30 (+1)
- $$
- 2 City Island Ave
- 4.4 (9509 reviews)
Description
Service follows a straightforward cafeteria-style dining setup. Diners grab their food to eat in the indoor or outdoor picnic setting overlooking the water.