Find Freddie & Pepper's Pizza and Check UWS Hours

Find Freddie & Pepper's at 303 Amsterdam Avenue in Manhattan for thin-crust pizza and Chilean empanadas. This Upper West Side neighborhood fixture has been operating since 1978, and its menu also includes heroes and pasta. Customers praise the crust's crispy texture, so compare an in-person counter stop with delivery: the review summary also notes occasional sogginess in delivered orders. Use the weekly schedule below to plan a visit rather than assuming the same closing time every day.

Address: 303 Amsterdam Avenue, Manhattan, New York
Listed weekly hours: Monday and Sunday 11 AM–9 PM; Tuesday–Thursday 11 AM–10 PM; Friday–Saturday 11 AM–11 PM (New York local time)
Setting: tiny, no-frills, counter-service shop
Listed price range: $13.50–$35 per person; individual item prices are not specified
Recorded rating: 4.4 out of 5 from 964 ratings
Phone: (212) 799-2378

Compare this shop by starting with the texture you want. Reviewers describe its thin crust as crispy, while the recorded menu also includes heroes, pasta, and empanadas. The setting is a tiny, no-frills counter-service space rather than a large dining room. That makes the useful choice an in-person slice stop versus delivery, not an assumption that every menu item or topping is available when you arrive.

An in-person stop lets you order at the counter in the small neighborhood shop. The review summary pairs praise for crisp crust with reports of occasional delivery sogginess and uneven service. Treat that as a review-based trade-off, not a guarantee about any particular order. Check the menu before choosing between slices, heroes, pasta, and empanadas, and avoid treating the photos as a promise of today's selection.

The weekly schedule opens at 11 AM every day. Closing is 9 PM on Monday and Sunday, 10 PM from Tuesday through Thursday, and 11 PM on Friday and Saturday. If you are planning an evening stop, Friday and Saturday have the latest listed closing, but the schedule does not establish holiday hours. Call (212) 799-2378 to check changes before making a special trip.

What price range is listed?
The listed range is $13.50–$35 per person. It does not specify an individual slice or empanada price.

How is the shop rated?
The recorded score is 4.4 out of 5 from 964 ratings. Customer feedback praises crust texture and also notes occasional delivery and service inconsistencies.

How long has the business been here?
The business summary describes this neighborhood fixture as operating since 1978.

How can I check changes before going?
Call (212) 799-2378 to confirm any changes to the listed weekly schedule.

Compare five more guides: Italian Flatbreads Imported Weekly From Pesaro Reach the West Village offers flatbreads; Upper West Side Italian With Wood Fired Pizza and Pasta Nights adds an Italian option; Chelsea Pizzeria Serving Thin Crust Pies and Lasagna Pizza keeps the crust comparison going. For two more food ideas, read Upper West Side Cafe for Croffles and Matcha, then Southwestern Dining With a Covered Patio on the Upper West Side.