East New York Pizza With Slices and Pies
Slices and whole pies for pickup from a Fulton Street pizzeria in East New York.
🍕 A Neighborhood Touchstone
There is a particular kind of Brooklyn loyalty attached to Caterina Pizza. For people who grew up in East New York, the Fulton Street pizzeria is part of their childhood memories. Longtime local figure Vito runs the neighborhood shop, with warm, family style hospitality giving the experience a personal feel.
Crispy, cheesy New York style pizza anchors the menu, with plain, pepperoni and chicken slices among the straightforward choices. Mozzarella sticks and salads sit alongside them, keeping the options familiar for an order that can stay with pizza or branch into a few sides. Inside, the space is simple and kept clean, and there is limited seating for a meal at this small neighborhood spot.
Hours run from 11 AM to 9 PM Monday through Thursday, 11 AM to 10 PM Friday and Saturday, and noon to 9 PM Sunday.
