Caterina Pizza

Located in East New York, this pizzeria is run by long-time local figure Vito. For many who grew up in the neighborhood, the shop acts as a nostalgic childhood touchstone. The menu focuses on straightforward options like plain, pepperoni, and chicken slices, as well as mozzarella sticks and salads. The indoor space is simple, small, and a bit run-down, but it is kept clean.