Columbus Avenue Italian Pizza And Pasta By The Slice

Order Columbus Avenue Italian pizza topped with cup-and-char pepperoni alongside generous plates of homemade pasta.

See which pizza slices are ready.

🍕 Counter Slices And Pastas

Anyone looking for Columbus Avenue Italian pizza will find plenty to like at Compari. The counter kitchen operates at 924 Columbus Avenue, serving New York style pies finished with cup-and-char pepperoni and imported toppings. Marcello and the team keep a selection of fresh slices ready for a quick lunch or dinner.

Beyond classic pizza, the kitchen prepares homemade pasta in generous portions alongside traditional panuozzo sandwiches. The owners moved directly from Italy, bringing authentic recipes and daily dessert specials that set this shop apart from standard slice counters. Each dish delivers reliable comfort without stretching your budget.

Compari welcomes guests Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to eight thirty PM, opening Sunday from noon to 8 PM. Doors remain closed on Monday, making an early weekend stop ideal for enjoying Columbus Avenue Italian pizza before the evening rush.


🍽️ Nearby Manhattan Pizza Spots

Ask Karpo for more information.