Mimi's Pizza

Located right on Broadway, this no-frills Upper West Side joint is a neighborhood staple for classic New York slices and casual Italian eats. The draw here is the dough—notably light and crispy—which forms the base for traditional rounds and square Grandma slices topped with everything from cacio e pepe and vodka sauce to cup-and-char pepperoni. The menu also covers hot heros and baked pastas, all served quickly and at budget-friendly prices. With limited space inside, it is a prime spot for a grab-and-go meal, whether you're taking your slices to a nearby park bench or making a quick pit stop off the West Side Highway.