Pizza Pete's
A snug, no-frills neighborhood fixture serving up crispy New York-style slices, Sicilian pies, and classic heros.
- Mon – Sun, 10:00 – 22:00
- $3.50 – $21.50
- 528 Columbus Ave
- 4.3 (543 reviews)
Description
Part of the community since the 1980s, this spot draws locals with budget-friendly prices, Chicago-style pies, rolls, and a dedicated Special Pizza. The staff behind the counter keeps the atmosphere welcoming, though the experience itself draws mixed reviews. Some visitors praise the flavorful, fresh slices, while others point to issues with consistency, noting slow service, maintenance lapses, or rubbery cheese.
Good to know
Near Central Park