
Arthur Avenue Cheese and Pastry Counters With Italian Market Meals in Seven Days
I match the meal to your appetite, not a ranking. Start with Arthur Avenue cheese and Italian market sandwiches, give pastry its own outing, then try Belmont dining rooms before a separate Inwood soda-shop trip. Built for first-year students in New York; weekdays suggest an order, not guaranteed opening days.
🧀 Monday Arthur Avenue Cheese at the Italian Market
For a newcomer, Arthur Avenue cheese makes more sense as lunch than as a shopping haul: Mike's Deli puts fresh mozzarella into substantial sandwiches inside the Italian market. ask about sandwich size before ordering, then take the short walk along Arthur Avenue to Morrone for a cannoli. This pairing suits two classmates; leave room for a single sweet rather than ordering a second meal.
🥐 Tuesday Pastry for a Smaller Appetite
After Monday's sandwich-and-sweet pairing, give pastry its own smaller outing at Egidio. This is for the freshman who wants a familiar coffee break while learning Belmont, not another full restaurant meal. The counter offers biscotti, cookies and cakes, so choose one sweet before adding extras. Bring a small carry bag if you plan to take anything back to campus.
🍝 Wednesday Settle Into Neapolitan Comfort
Once you have met the counters, move to Mario's for a proper sit-down meal. Its Neapolitan-Italian cooking gives a new student a different way into Arthur Avenue: lasagna or manicotti rather than another sandwich. Your match is a classmate who wants conversation over dinner. Before ordering, ask how substantial your chosen dish is and decide together whether dessert belongs in this meal.
🍅 Thursday Let Portions Set the Pace
Enzo's follows the first dining-room visit because it makes portion planning the lesson. Its generous Italian-American plates suit a lively, unhurried meal; choose it for classmates ready to linger, not someone squeezing dinner between commitments. Start with one main decision per person, ask the server about portion sizes, and add more only after you understand what the table needs.
🍕 Friday Match the Table to Pizza
After two pasta-minded evenings, change the conversation at Michaelangelo's to brick-oven pies. This suits a freshman meeting a new friend: choosing toppings gives you something easy to discuss without turning dinner into a performance. The restaurant also serves Italian-American entrees, but agree on the pizza plan first. Ask about pie size before deciding whether your table needs another dish.
🍽️ Saturday Share a Communal Table
After choosing meals around your own appetite, make Dominick's the group lesson. This Arthur Avenue restaurant serves large family-style Italian-American portions at communal tables without a printed menu. It suits freshmen ready to meet the room, not someone seeking privacy. Bring two classmates, ask the server what your group should share, and clarify the dishes before anyone orders a separate main.
🍦 Sunday Take a Separate Inwood Detour
Finish with neighborhood life beyond Belmont at Dichter Pharmacy & Soda Shop, a separate trip to Inwood in Manhattan. Send a freshman here for an ice-cream counter reset after the week's fuller meals, not pretend it is another Arthur Avenue stop. Choose one soda-fountain treat that fits your appetite, and check your transit route to 4953 Broadway before leaving campus.











