North Beach has a main street problem. Columbus Avenue is where the tour buses stop, and a stretch of it operates accordingly — hosts on the pavement, laminated menus in four languages, food priced for people who will not be back. One block in any direction, on Green, Vallejo, Union, Grant and the stairways climbing Telegraph Hill, the neighbourhood that has been eating here for a hundred and fifty years is still doing it, mostly in rooms with twelve tables and no host.
The rooms worth finding here are small, cash-friendly and keep hours that suit the owner rather than the visitor. Ask Karpo which of them are open tonight and how long the wait is before you walk up the hill.
The rule that sorts the two North Beaches
If someone is standing outside trying to bring you in, walk on. That single filter removes almost everything not worth eating on Columbus and costs you nothing, because the rooms that do not need to do it are thirty seconds away. The second filter is the menu length: a page is a good sign, four pages with photographs is not, and a handwritten insert is the best sign of all.
The third is who is inside. North Beach still has a resident Italian-American community, plus a large population of people who work in the neighbourhood. A room with regulars in it at seven on a Tuesday is telling you everything a rating cannot.
Grant Avenue, above Columbus
Upper Grant, from Vallejo north toward Filbert, is the best eating and drinking street in the neighbourhood and one of the most pleasant in San Francisco. It is narrow, mostly low buildings, and the businesses skew old — bars that have been there since the fifties, a couple of tiny restaurants, a bakery, an art supply shop. Nothing about it is designed for visitors, which is exactly the point.
This is where to go for a slow evening: an aperitivo at a bar with six stools, dinner at a room that seats twenty, and a walk up the hill afterwards.
The stairways and what is at the top
Telegraph Hill is threaded with public stairways — the Filbert Steps and the Greenwich Steps being the famous pair — and the blocks around their base hold a handful of restaurants that get almost no foot traffic because nobody walks up a hill by accident. The reward is a table with a view down the hill and a room that is quiet on a Saturday. Climb the Filbert Steps afterwards for the cottages, the gardens and the wild parrots, which are real and loud and have been there for decades.
Where North Beach meets Chinatown
The two-block seam either side of Broadway, where North Beach becomes Chinatown, is the most interesting eating in the area and the least written about. Cantonese barbecue counters next to Italian delis, a Vietnamese room between two bars, dumpling windows opposite a pizzeria. Prices drop sharply as you cross Broadway heading south, and the hours run later. If the North Beach room you wanted has an hour wait, walking two blocks south solves it entirely.
Practical notes
Most of these places do not take reservations and several are cash-preferred; the smaller the room, the more likely both are true. Go early or late — the neighbourhood fills between seven and eight and empties quickly after. Do not drive: North Beach parking is famously bad and the garages fill on weekends, while the 30, 8, 45 and the Powell-Mason cable car all run through. Bring a layer for the walk back down the hill. And if a room has a handwritten specials board, order from it — that is the dish the kitchen cared about today.
The bars that came with the neighbourhood
Eating off Columbus works best when it is bracketed by the neighbourhood's older bars, several of which have been in place since the middle of the last century and none of which require a plan. An aperitivo before dinner and a nightcap after, both within two blocks, is the shape of a North Beach evening and has been for seventy years.
This is also where the neighbourhood's literary history is still visible rather than commemorated — the bookshop, the bars around it, and the alley between them are working businesses rather than a museum, which is the reason to go.
Timing matters more than the specific address in this neighbourhood. Between about seven and eight-thirty every small room here is full and every wait is long; before six-thirty and after nine the same rooms are half empty and the service is better. North Beach rewards eating early or eating late more than almost anywhere else in San Francisco.
Tags: #SanFrancisco #NorthBeach #TelegraphHill #HiddenSF #UpperGrant #FilbertSteps #Chinatown #SFRestaurants #WhereToEatSF #ItalianSF #SFEats #NeighborhoodGuide #LocalsOnly #BayArea
Sources consulted: sf.gov · sfrecpark.org · sftravel.com
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
The small rooms in this neighbourhood keep owner's hours and fill without warning on the nights nobody expects. Ask Karpo which of them are open and seating right now, how long the wait is, and what is on the specials board tonight.
