A 14-inch Totonno's Traditional Pizza costs $25, and the useful detail is the narrow window in which you can actually get one: Saturday or Sunday from noon to 5:30 p.m. The Coney Island institution is now takeout and delivery only, with no indoor seating, so this is not a drop-in lunch followed by a table near the coal oven. It is a planned weekend collection from 1524 Neptune Avenue. The traditional pie brings mozzarella, tomato, grated cheese, oil, a thin crust and the char that has defined Totonno's for generations. The white pizza costs the same and strips the order back to mozzarella, grated cheese and oil.
Karpo can check the current weekend hours, help judge the likely wait, and point to a nearby backup if the last dough has gone.
A 1924 institution with a much smaller service window
Totonno's opened in Coney Island in 1924, after Anthony "Totonno" Pero, a pizza maker connected to Lombardi's in Manhattan, started his own pizzeria. The family says its grandchildren continue to operate the restaurant, making it one of America's oldest continuously run family-owned pizzerias. Its tradition rests on handmade mozzarella, imported Italian ingredients and dough made daily, never refrigerated. The coal oven and crisp, charred crust remain central to the place, even though the present-day visit is reduced to a box carried away from the shop rather than a meal inside it.
That history has survived more than a change in format. Totonno's endured a fire in 1997, a major fire in 2009 and Hurricane Sandy in 2012 before reopening in 2013. It received the James Beard America's Classics award in 2009. The old phrase "as long as there's dough" belongs to the restaurant's identity, but it should not be treated as a confirmed current sellout policy. What is clear is the present schedule: Saturday and Sunday afternoons only, roughly 11 hours across the week, with reported waits around opening and a risk of selling out later in the afternoon.
The two pies that make the order straightforward
The Traditional Pizza is the core order. At $25 for 14 inches, it combines mozzarella, tomato, grated cheese and oil over a thin crust, with the coal-oven char doing much of the work. It is the clearest expression of what Totonno's is known for, and a sensible choice when the point of the trip is to taste the restaurant's established style rather than assemble a complicated topping list. Two traditional pies come to $50 before tax, delivery charges and app fees, which makes sharing or ordering for a small group easier to plan.
The White Pizza is also $25 for 14 inches, built from mozzarella, grated cheese and oil. It is the minimalist classic and is frequently singled out as a signature choice. Ordering one of each gives a useful comparison without adding menu guesswork: tomato and char in one box, a simpler cheese-and-oil balance in the other. Skip expecting slices, because the current official menu lists whole 14-inch pies rather than individual portions. Also skip treating delivery-app totals as the menu price; the $25 figure is before the charges and fees attached to delivery.
The former dining room now tells you how to order
Inside the current room, chairs are stacked on tables, making the loss of indoor seating plain rather than temporary-looking. A narrow counter booth holds four delivery tablets, and stacks of napkins and paper plates sit by the door for people collecting food. The arrangement feels practical: this is a service point for takeaway and delivery, not a dining room waiting to be filled. The walls still carry family photographs and clipped articles, while the dark wood, cream paper and coal-dark surfaces preserve some of the old visual character.
There are no reservations because there is no current table service to reserve. Online ordering runs through Grubhub, DoorDash, Uber Eats or Slice, and the four tablets at the booth reflect that setup. Collection still requires timing, particularly on a weekend afternoon when queues are reported around opening. The practical choice is to decide whether the box should be collected or delivered before setting out. Either way, the former room is part of the story, not part of the meal: expect paper plates, a closed box and a route back into Coney Island.
Plan around noon, not the end of the afternoon
Totonno's is closed Monday through Friday and open Saturday and Sunday from noon to 5:30 p.m. That schedule makes the opening part of the afternoon the safest planning point, especially when the pie itself is the reason to go. Recent reporting says to expect planning and a wait, with lines around opening and a late-afternoon sellout risk. The useful distinction is between waiting for a pie and arriving after the day has already narrowed. A late visit may be quieter, but it carries the greater chance that the order you wanted is no longer available.
The address is 1524 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224. Take the F train to Avenue X, then walk to Neptune Avenue between West 15th and West 16th Streets. Street parking is listed as an option, although there is no verified dedicated parking facility. This is a simple route once the opening hours are in view, but the limited schedule changes the shape of the trip. Check the current situation before leaving, allow for the reported wait, and do not build an indoor meal or a reservation into the plan.
Totonno's versus L&B Spumoni Gardens
L&B Spumoni Gardens at 2725 86th Street is the more flexible alternative when a group wants a broader day out. It is a Brooklyn institution for Sicilian pizza and spumoni, with indoor and outdoor dining. That gives it an advantage over Totonno's for anyone who wants to sit down, linger or make the meal less dependent on a short weekend service window. Totonno's offers a different tradeoff: a 1924 Coney Island coal-oven tradition, thin crust and char, but only as takeout and delivery under the current operation.
The choice is therefore less about declaring one pie better than the other and more about what the afternoon needs. Choose Totonno's when the coal-oven crust, the traditional or white 14-inch pie, and the old Coney Island address are the point. Choose L&B when seating, Sicilian pizza or spumoni matters more, or when the timing at Neptune Avenue is not workable. Ruby's Bar & Grill at 1213 Riegelmann Boardwalk is another Coney Island option, with indoor and outdoor seating and ocean views. Totonno's remains the focused pizza stop, but it is no longer the easy one.
- Address: 1524 Neptune Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11224.
- Hours: Saturday and Sunday, noon-5:30 p.m.; closed Monday through Friday.
- Reservations: None; current service is takeout and delivery only, with ordering through Grubhub, DoorDash, Uber Eats or Slice.
- Getting there: Take the F train to Avenue X, then walk to Neptune Avenue between West 15th and West 16th Streets; street parking is listed as an option.
- Price band: $25 for a 14-inch Traditional Pizza or White Pizza; two pies cost $50 before tax, delivery charges and app fees.
- Timing: Expect planning and a possible wait; lines are reported around opening and late-afternoon sellout risk is possible.
Tags: #NewYorkCity #ConeyIsland #BrooklynPizza #TotonnoS #CoalOvenPizza #PizzaNearMe #WeekendPlans #NeptuneAvenue #NYCPizza #PizzaTakeout #PizzaDelivery #WhitePizza #TraditionalPizza
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Before heading to Totonno's, ask Karpo for the current weekend hours, the live wait, the route from the F train, or the best nearby backup.
