At Lucali, the first decision is not which pizza to order. It is whether you can arrive with cash, bring your own drink, and put your name down at 4:00 PM for a 5:00 PM opening. The Carroll Gardens pizzeria is small, full-service and built around large thin-crust pies, so dinner can take more planning than a quick slice. If the waitlist is the wrong shape for your evening, F&F Pizzeria offers a more practical counter-service alternative nearby. Juliana’s gives you a coal-fired sit-down meal in DUMBO, while L&B Spumoni Gardens takes you across Brooklyn for Sicilian slices, round pies and spumoni.
Ask Karpo in the app to compare Lucali, F&F, Juliana’s and L&B Spumoni Gardens by waitlist, opening time, price and route from where you are.
Pizza Near Me in Carroll Gardens: Lucali Is Cash-Only and BYOB
Lucali is a small, full-service Brooklyn pizzeria at 575 Henry Street, Carroll Gardens, centred on large thin-crust pies, calzones and a short list of toppings. The room occupies a former neighbourhood candy-store space, a building Mark Iacono wanted to save, and its exposed brick, candlelit tables and visible wood-burning oven make the setting part of the meal. The practical rules matter as much as the atmosphere: Lucali is cash-only and BYOB. One correction to the old shorthand is needed, though. It is not operating with no menu; Lucali now publishes a concise online menu listing pizza, calzones and toppings.
Lucali opens Monday and Wednesday through Sunday from 5:00 PM to 11:00 PM and is closed Tuesday. There are no reservations. Staff begin taking names for the first-come, same-day waitlist at 4:00 PM, one hour before opening, so dinner timing starts before the doors open. Takeout orders can also be placed by phone or in person from 4:00 PM. A large pie with basil is $32, a large calzone is $29, and toppings cost $3 to $8. Go here if you want a lingering, intimate dinner and can carry cash, bring your own drink and remain nearby after joining the list.
F&F Pizzeria, Carroll Gardens — the easier walk-in slice option
F&F Pizzeria is the nearby counter-service answer when Lucali’s waitlist is too demanding. At 459 Court Street in Carroll Gardens, it serves New York-style slices and whole pies in a materially more casual setting. The shop comes from the team behind Frankies 457 Spuntino and offers classic, Sicilian and specialty pies. Its compact converted-garage storefront has a visible pizza counter and a small rear courtyard or patio, giving it a bright, functional neighbourhood feel rather than Lucali’s candlelit, full-service format. It accepts takeout and delivery, making it the more useful choice when you want pizza without turning the evening into a queue-management exercise.
F&F is open Sunday through Thursday from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM. A regular pie is $29, a pepperoni pie is $35, and specialty pies run up to $50. That puts it close to Lucali on the basic pie price while offering a simpler path to lunch or an early dinner. It suits solo diners, families, groups that need flexibility and anyone who wants a slice or whole pie near Carroll Gardens without arriving an hour before service. Lucali and F&F are both close to the F/G Carroll Street station, so F&F is the practical first comparison when the waitlist is the deciding factor.
Juliana’s Pizza, DUMBO — coal-fired pies with daytime service
Juliana’s Pizza brings a traditional coal-fired, sit-down Brooklyn-pizzeria experience to 19 Old Fulton Street in DUMBO. The restaurant occupies the historic space associated with Patsy Grimaldi, with exposed brick, vintage photographs and the visible presence of a high-heat coal-fired oven beneath the Brooklyn Bridge. It is a different proposition from both Carroll Gardens options: you are travelling for the setting as well as the pie, and the service day begins at lunchtime. Juliana’s also offers online ordering, so the process is less dependent on a cash-only, same-day waitlist than Lucali’s.
Juliana’s serves daily from 11:30 AM to 3:15 PM and 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM. The kitchen closes between 3:15 PM and 4:00 PM each day for tending and restocking the coal-fired oven, so do not plan around a continuous afternoon service. A large 18-inch Margherita is $30.50, a medium 16-inch Margherita is $27.50, and a personal 11-inch Margherita is $18.50. Online orders are limited to two pies. Choose it for a DUMBO outing, a daytime pizza meal or a sit-down coal-fired pie when Lucali’s 5:00 PM start and waitlist do not fit your plans. It is about a six-minute walk from the A/C High Street station, with limited metered parking on Old Fulton and Water Streets.
L&B Spumoni Gardens, Bensonhurst — Sicilian slices and an all-day garden
L&B Spumoni Gardens is the farthest option here and the one with the broadest format. At 2725 86th Street in Bensonhurst, the long-running pizzeria and restaurant is best known for thick Sicilian pizza and house spumoni, but it also serves round pies and a full Italian-American menu. The original Bensonhurst location offers indoor and outdoor dining in a large old-school open-air garden, with red chairs, marble tables, green flower-decorated walls and a neon garden sign. This is not a quick Carroll Gardens detour. It is a destination for choosing between formats, sitting down and finishing with the house dessert.
L&B is open Monday through Sunday from 11:00 AM to 11:30 PM. A Sicilian slice costs $4.50, a Sicilian pie is $35, and a round pie is $24. The long hours make it the most flexible option for lunch, late dinner or a group that wants more than one kind of pizza, while the indoor and outdoor seating gives you room to settle in. Go here when square Sicilian pizza and spumoni matter more than proximity to Carroll Gardens. Its Bensonhurst address is a substantial cross-Brooklyn trip and is more practical by car or rideshare than as a spontaneous walk from the Carroll Street station.
How to choose
For pizza near Carroll Gardens, start with the decision that changes the evening: Lucali is the intimate, full-service choice, but its 4:00 PM waitlist, 5:00 PM opening, cash-only policy and BYOB rule require preparation. F&F is the sensible nearby alternative for slices, takeout, delivery, lunch or an early dinner. Its regular pie is $29 against Lucali’s $32 large pie with basil, but the key difference is not the small price gap. It is the ease of walking in and ordering. Both are close to the F/G Carroll Street station, though Lucali’s wait can mean staying in the neighbourhood after you have put your name down.
Juliana’s is the right comparison if your plans already include DUMBO, the Brooklyn Bridge area or a daytime meal. Its service break from 3:15 PM to 4:00 PM and limited two-pie online orders are useful details to settle before travelling. L&B is the outlier: its 86th Street Bensonhurst location is open all day, serves both Sicilian and round pizza, and offers indoor and outdoor dining, but it is a serious cross-Brooklyn journey. Treat it as a planned destination, usually by car or rideshare, rather than a substitute for a quick Carroll Gardens stop. Ask Karpo in the app to compare the route and timing before you leave.
One correction before you search
Outdated guides that place Grimaldi’s at 19 Old Fulton Street are wrong. Grimaldi’s relocated to 1 Front Street, while Juliana’s now occupies the former Old Fulton Street space. If you search for a coal-fired pizza near the Brooklyn Bridge and follow an old address, you can end up at the wrong restaurant before the oven has even become the problem.
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
Tags: #pizzanearme #newyorkcity #carrollgardens #brooklynpizza #lucali #fandfpizzeria #julianaspizza #dumbo #landbspumonigardens #bensonhurst #nycrestaurants #thincrustpizza #sicilianpizza
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Before leaving, ask Karpo in the app to check which pizza stop fits your timing, whether Lucali’s 4:00 PM same-day waitlist is worth building your evening around, and how to order the venues in a sensible route. For Lucali, carry cash and plan to remain nearby after putting your name down. For a quicker Carroll Gardens meal, compare F&F first; choose Juliana’s for a DUMBO visit and L&B for a planned Bensonhurst trip by car or rideshare.
