The Record Nobody Wants
In the 34th minute of Argentina's Round of 16 match against Egypt at NRG Stadium in Houston, Lionel Messi placed the ball on the penalty spot with his team leading 1-0. The stadium held its breath. Messi, the greatest footballer of all time, struck the ball to the goalkeeper's left. Egypt's Mohamed El-Shenawy dived the right way and pushed it wide. The miss was Messi's second penalty failure of the 2026 World Cup — he had also fired wide against Austria in the final group stage match — making him the first player in 96 years of World Cup history to miss two penalties in the same tournament edition, excluding shootouts.
Can't believe Messi missed two penalties? Text Karpo for expert analysis, stat breakdowns, and all the World Cup storylines you need.
The Numbers: 4 Out of 8
Messi's penalty record at the World Cup now reads like a statistical anomaly for a player of his caliber. Across four World Cups — 2014, 2018, 2022, and 2026 — he has taken eight penalties in open play and converted just four. A 50 percent success rate would be considered poor for any professional footballer; for the player widely regarded as the best ever, it is genuinely startling. By comparison, Cristiano Ronaldo converted six of seven World Cup penalties across his career. Zinedine Zidane scored all four of his. Even Neymar, whose overall penalty record is less celebrated, converted three of four at World Cups. Messi's penalty struggles at the biggest tournament represent the single most puzzling weakness in an otherwise flawless career.
The Austria Miss: Group Stage Warning Signs
The first missed penalty came on June 28, in Argentina's final group stage match against Austria at Arrowhead Stadium in Kansas City. With the score at 2-0 to Argentina, Messi stepped up in the 67th minute with the chance to complete a hat-trick and extend the match beyond reach. He drove the ball wide of the left post — not saved, not deflected, simply missed. The Argentine media, initially forgiving given the comfortable scoreline, noted that Messi's run-up had been shorter than usual and his body position appeared to lean backward at the point of contact. In retrospect, it was a warning sign that went unheeded.
The Egypt Miss: Nearly Fatal
The Egypt miss was far more consequential. At 1-0, a converted penalty would have given Argentina a two-goal cushion and likely killed the match as a contest. Instead, the miss kept Egypt alive. Twenty minutes later, Egypt equalized through Omar Marmoush. By the 78th minute, Egypt had gone 2-0 up on goals from Marmoush and Mostafa Mohamed, and Argentina were staring at elimination. Only a stunning 14-minute comeback — goals from Lautaro Martinez in the 79th minute, Julian Alvarez in the 85th minute, and Enzo Fernandez in the 93rd minute — saved Argentina. Without the comeback, Messi's missed penalty would have been the defining image of his final World Cup.
The Psychology of Penalty Taking at 39
Sports psychologists have long studied the relationship between age, pressure, and penalty performance. Dr. Geir Jordet, a professor at the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences and the world's leading researcher on penalty kicks, has argued that older players are more susceptible to penalty misses because they carry the accumulated weight of previous failures. For Messi, who missed a penalty in the 2016 Copa America final (which led to his temporary international retirement) and scored the crucial penalty in the 2022 World Cup final shootout, the psychological landscape of the penalty spot is uniquely complex. At 39, with his body slowing and his World Cup career ending, the pressure of each penalty is magnified beyond what younger players experience.
Scaloni's Dilemma: Who Takes the Next One?
Argentina coach Lionel Scaloni now faces a delicate tactical and diplomatic question: should Messi remain on penalty duty? The coach deflected the question at his post-match press conference, saying only that "Leo is our captain and our best player — the decisions on the pitch are his." But the numbers suggest that Julian Alvarez, who has scored 14 of his last 15 penalties at club level, or Lautaro Martinez, who scored in the penalty shootout against Switzerland, might be more reliable options. The counterargument is equally powerful: removing Messi from penalty duty would represent a public acknowledgment of decline that could affect his confidence in other areas of his game. For now, the decision remains with Messi himself.
The Broader Legacy Question
Messi's two missed penalties at the 2026 World Cup will not define his legacy — that legacy was secured by the 2022 World Cup triumph, the eight Ballon d'Or awards, and 24 years of performances that transcended sport. But they add a footnote of vulnerability to a career that sometimes seemed superhuman. The missed penalties remind us that even the greatest athletes are subject to moments of fallibility, that the penalty spot is uniquely cruel in its exposure of human weakness, and that the World Cup, more than any other tournament, finds and magnifies the flaws in even the most complete players. Messi will take another penalty if Argentina are awarded one in the quarterfinal against Switzerland. Whether he scores or misses, 82,000 people will hold their breath. That is the power of imperfection.
Tags: Lionel Messi, penalty miss, World Cup 2026, Argentina, record, Egypt, Austria, two penalties, quarterfinal, Switzerland
Sources consulted: Yahoo Sports · beIN Sports · SofaScore · ESPN
All trademarks, team names, league names, and player likenesses mentioned in this article are the property of their respective owners and are used here for informational and editorial purposes only.
Ask Karpo First
Want to explore Messi's full World Cup penalty history or preview Argentina's quarterfinal? Ask Karpo for Messi's career penalty statistics, Argentina's path to the semifinal, and the most dramatic penalty moments in World Cup history.
