Sheepshead Bay Pizzeria With Classic Slices and Hero Sandwiches
Grab classic slices at a Sheepshead Bay pizzeria where heroes and Italian entrees share the counter menu.
🍕 A Neighborhood Slice Counter
Delmar Pizzeria is a Sheepshead Bay pizzeria that has fed Brooklyn from 1957 onward, and fresh, classic slices remain the main event. The counter at 1668 Sheepshead Bay Road keeps prices inexpensive and the format simple, making it an easy neighborhood stop for a quick slice.
Beyond the pizza, the menu runs to heroes, classic Italian entrees and appetizers, which gives a group a few directions without changing the destination. Eating in means tables but no servers, with counter service handling every order. Grab a seat and take the meal at your own pace.
Doors open Monday through Saturday from 11 AM to 9 PM and Sunday from noon to 9 PM. The kitchen is known for consistent flavor, which keeps regulars returning for the same slice they ordered last time, and the shop holds a 4.3 rating across more than eight hundred reviews.
