Romantic West Village Restaurant in a Carriage House With Piano
Romantic dinner in the West Village, with Beef Wellington, live piano and a three course prix fixe by candlelight.
🕯️ Candlelit Carriage House Dinner
One if by Land, Two if by Sea is a romantic West Village restaurant set inside an eighteenth century carriage house at 17 Barrow St. Candlelit tables sit beneath soaring ceilings and glowing chandeliers, two brick fireplaces warm the room, and live piano carries through dinner. A lush courtyard adds greenery, and diners give it a 4.2 average across 1,338 reviews, praising the storybook mood and attentive service.
The menu leans American, and the two signature dishes are Beef Wellington and a chocolate soufflé for the finish. Choose a three course prix fixe or a seven course tasting menu, depending on how long the evening should run. Prices sit firmly upscale, and the dress code is smart casual.
Dinner runs Wednesday through Sunday from 5 PM, with a later close on Friday and Saturday. Reservations go through OpenTable, the simplest way to lock in an anniversary or date night table in this carriage house dining room.
