Prima Pizza Woodhaven: Hours, Slices and Sicilian Pie

For pizza in Woodhaven, Prima Pizza at 92-15 Jamaica Ave is the counter where the real decision is crust: a standard thin slice or the thick Sicilian pie. Both leave the same kitchen, so the choice is about appetite and texture rather than two different restaurants, and the Sicilian square is the one worth planning a stop around if you want a heavier, bakery-style base under the cheese.

Hours decide the trip. Prima Pizza serves Tuesday through Sunday from 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM and stays closed on Monday, so a Monday craving needs another address. Takeout and delivery are both on offer, which makes the Jamaica Avenue stop workable either as a quick counter pickup or as a meal at home without a table-service plan.

The caveat is the counter itself. Ratings sit at 4.5 from 359 reviews and praise the Sicilian and buffalo chicken pies plus friendly staff, but some regulars describe uneven hospitality from the owner. Plan the visit for the food and expect a direct, no-frills transaction. The next question is which style to order and when to arrive, and both are covered below.

Address: 92-15 Jamaica Ave, Woodhaven, Queens, New York
Hours: Tuesday–Sunday 11:00 AM–9:30 PM · Monday closed
Phone: (718) 487-3932
Rating: 4.5 out of 5 from 359 reviews
Price signal: $ on the asset record
Service: takeout available and delivery offered
Menu range: slices, Sicilian pies, calzones, rolls, heroes, pasta, desserts
Website: primapizzaofwoodhaven.com
Business status: operational on the asset record

The thin slice is the everyday order here: a standard New York base that eats quickly and travels well if you are carrying it a few blocks. The Sicilian pie is the opposite experience, a thick rectangular bake with a taller crumb, and it is the reason people name this shop when they want something more substantial than a quick counter slice.

A third route exists in the buffalo chicken pizza, one of the named specialties and the pie that shows up most often in positive reviews alongside the Sicilian. If you are ordering for more than one person, the practical split is one thin slice for the walk and a Sicilian square for the table, so nobody has to pick a single format.

Partial pies work too: the menu covers calzones, rolls, heroes, pasta and desserts, so a group that does not agree on pizza still has options. Decide the format before you arrive, because the wait at the counter is shorter when you are not choosing between styles in the queue.

The weekly window is the one detail worth checking before you travel: Tuesday to Sunday, 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM, with Monday closed entirely. That makes Tuesday lunch the first safe slot of the week and Sunday evening the last, and a Monday plan needs a different Woodhaven address rather than a hopeful walk to Jamaica Avenue.

Mid-afternoon is the calmest stretch for a counter order, between the lunch push and the dinner rush, which suits anyone who wants to ask about the Sicilian bake before committing. Evening orders close at 9:30 PM, so a late dinner has to start earlier than it would at a shop that runs past ten.

If you are driving, treat the address as the anchor and expect a neighborhood commercial strip rather than a lot with dedicated parking. The store also keeps a delivery window inside those same hours, which means a late-week order should be placed before the kitchen nears its 9:30 PM close instead of at the edge of it.

Takeout and delivery are both offered, and reviews consistently single out the delivery side as the strong one, with hot pies arriving as the most repeated compliment. That makes a home order a reasonable default if you are already nearby in Woodhaven, while a counter pickup suits anyone who wants to check the slice case before buying.

For a delivery order, confirm the format first: a Sicilian pie carries more weight and heat than a stack of thin slices, so it survives a short trip better. The buffalo chicken pizza has the same advantage and is the specialty most often named favorably, which makes it the safer pick when you are ordering blind.

One caveat carries over from the counter. Some reviews describe uneven hospitality, and the phone or in-person exchange can be brisk, so keep the order simple and specific rather than building a long custom request. Prices stay at the low end of the range on the asset record, which is part of why the shop works as a routine stop rather than an occasion.

What are Prima Pizza's hours in Woodhaven?
Tuesday through Sunday, 11:00 AM to 9:30 PM. The shop is closed on Monday, so plan a different day for a Jamaica Avenue visit.

Where is Prima Pizza located?
92-15 Jamaica Ave in Woodhaven, Queens, New York, on the neighborhood's main commercial strip.

Is Prima Pizza closed on Monday?
Yes. Monday has no service hours on the asset record, and the weekly window resumes Tuesday at 11:00 AM.

What is the difference between the thin slice and the Sicilian pie?
The thin slice is a standard New York base that eats quickly; the Sicilian is a thick rectangular bake with a taller crumb and a heavier finish.

Does Prima Pizza offer takeout and delivery?
Both. Takeout and delivery are listed for the shop, and delivery is the service reviews mention most favorably.

What should I order on a first visit?
The Sicilian pie and the buffalo chicken pizza are the two most often praised, with standard thin-crust slices as the everyday order.

How is Prima Pizza rated?
4.5 out of 5 from 359 reviews, with praise for the pies and staff alongside occasional complaints about service attitude.

What phone number does the shop list?
(718) 487-3932, the contact number on the asset record for the Woodhaven location.

Can I order delivery late in the evening?
Delivery runs inside the same Tuesday-to-Sunday window and stops at 9:30 PM, so a late-week order should be placed well before closing.

Keep planning around Woodhaven after a slice. A Woodhaven bakery on Jamaica Avenue pairs guava pastries with Italian breads for a coffee stop, and an older Woodhaven pizza counter with garlic knots has served the same strip for over 50 years. In Ozone Park, a Sicilian bake with cheese under the sauce at 96-15 Liberty Ave offers a second thick-crust comparison, while a cash-only Dominican counter on 76-20 Jamaica Avenue covers breakfast and ribs when pizza is not the mood. Further out, a brick oven in Forest Hills at 107-23 Metropolitan Ave adds meatballs and closes Mondays. Together they map a short Queens pizza crawl without leaving the borough.