Pizza Shack
4.6 (210)restaurant
4.6 (210)This friendly Manhattan spot serves classic New York slices alongside board games and Cinnamon Toast Crunch milkshakes.
Description
Behind the counter, slices get a quick reheat in the oven, with options stretching to Grandma and Sicilian crusts that you can request extra crispy. Beyond the pies, the kitchen turns out strombolis, rolls, and hot sandwiches alongside a wide selection of ice cream. The space itself is kept clean and casual, detailed with graffiti-lined walls and humorous signs.
Selected reviews
Good to know
Grubhub & DoorDashFast service
Also featured in
Why a Sunny New York Week Runs on Ice Cream Reward StopsScoop pauses · Seated breaks · Flexible outings
Rockefeller Center Pizza With Catering OrdersSicilian pies · Garlic knots · Gluten free
Upper East Side Pizza With Thin Crust SlicesEating pizza · Gluten free pies · 4.7 rating
Murray Hill Pizza With Calzones and WingsVodka slices · Indoor seating
Lower East Side Thin Crust Pizza and BeerCasual dining · Craft beers · Outdoor tables
Gluten Free Pizza Slices on the Upper East SideSlice counter · Gluten free options · York Avenue
Halal Thin Crust Pizza and Vodka Slices on East Houston NYCCounter service · 147 E Houston · 4.8 stars
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza in Manhattan on MacDougal StreetPizza restaurant · Private events · Manhattan dining
Theater District Pizza Slices Open Late at Famous PopsSpecialty Pies · Beer Selection · Theater District
Thin Crust Pizza and Specialty Pies on Lexington AveItalian dining · Beer pours · Manhattan restaurant
East Village Artichoke Pizza Slice on East 14th StreetPizza stop · No seating · Open daily
East Harlem Coal Fired Pizza on First Avenue, NYCItalian dining · Cash only takeout · 2287 1st Ave
Midtown Pizza Slices Reheated Extra Crispy on RequestCounter dining · Standing room · Pasta available
East Village Late-Night Slices With Cold-Fermented DoughEating pizza · Gas deck oven · Outdoor tables
Staten Island Crispy Pizza Slices and Classic HeroesItalian heroes · Opens daily · Seated dining
Meatpacking Neapolitan Pizza Across From the WhitneyPersonal pizza · Patio seating · 4.7 rating
Halal Pizza in Ozone Park With Buffalo Chicken Slices and PastaHalal Italian · Specialty slices · Daily service
Late-Night Chicken and Pizza With Yucca Fries Until 1 AMComfort food · Outdoor seating · Delivery available
Late-Night Halal Pizza on the Lower East Side Until 3 AMCounter bites · 61 Delancey Street · Daily service
East Village Late-Night Pizza With Thick Upside Down SlicesPizza counter · Avenue B · 5.0 rating