Nate's Detroit Pizza · 86 5th Ave #2082 | New York

This hole-in-the-wall counter is run by a former Detroiter who preps his pies with homemade ingredients. Guests pop in for quick slices, with options ranging from standard cheese to hot honey and vodka truffle. The service is highly hands-on; owner Nate is known to watch the bakes closely, even refiring slices on the spot to ensure they land just right.