Milk Bar Nolita

Christina Tosi's bakery serves its signature cookies and Milk Bar Pie from this Nolita spot. While the brand's recipes are famous, visitors report highly mixed opinions on the actual desserts. The colorful birthday cake has been described as dry, and even the soft serve divides tastes. Despite the uneven feedback on the sweets, the staff is known for being exceptionally friendly. It remains a quick, sidewalk-facing stop for those curious to try the menu for themselves.