Make My Cake
This beloved Harlem bakery is famous for its rich, Southern-style cakes, pies, and warm neighborhood hospitality.
- Mon, Sun, 10:00 – 19:30; Tue – Sat, 11:00 – 19:30
- $$
- 409 W 125th St
- 4.3 (7 reviews)
Description
Beyond the signature cakes, Make My Cake menu features a wide selection of baked goods, from cookies and pastries to creamy cheesecakes and cupcakes. The bakery also accommodates custom orders. Longtime patrons, some returning for over two decades, prize cake slices so rich and delectable they end up eaten immediately in the car, though you can also order them as whole cakes.
Good to know
Custom orders