Lickety Split
A beloved City Island staple where friendly staff scoop up rich ice cream flavors like classic rum raisin.
- Mon – Wed, 14:30 – 21:00; Thu, 12:30 – 21:00; Fri – Sat, 12:30 – 22:00; Sun, 12:30 – 21:30
- 295 City Island Avenue
- 4.5 (12 reviews)
Description
Returning to this long-standing spot is a ritual for some, with visitors who once dropped by with friends now bringing their families. Alongside the standard scoops, the shop serves birthday cake milkshakes, doled out in generous portions. For many, it is a customary stop during any visit to City Island.