La Villa Pizzeria
A Dyker Heights staple serving wood-fired pizzas, classic pastas, and neighborhood favorites like calamari and banana pudding.
- Mon – Wed, 11:00 – 21:00; Thu – Sat, 11:00 – 21:30; Sun, 12:00 – 21:00
- $17 - $29
- 1529 86th Street
- 4.6 (1244 reviews)
Description
Located on 86th Street, this spot offers a classic Italian-American lineup, though the execution draws mixed reactions. While the cappuccino and funghi pizza win over fans, others note occasional inconsistencies in both the pizza dough texture and the attentiveness of the service. The wood-fired pies don't always achieve the perfect bake, but the comfort-food classics keep it a familiar option.