Joyce's Tavern

Run by the O'Toole family in Eltingville Town since 1966, this spot maintains a neighborhood feel that draws steady local crowds. Inside, the space offers a warm, traditional pub atmosphere, while the back deck provides a rare neighborhood amenity: outdoor dining shielded from the noise of the main street traffic. Alongside the standard draft list and specialty cocktails, the kitchen accommodates varied diets with gluten-free options. It is spacious enough to host large group gatherings, though off-site delivery can sometimes be hit-or-miss compared to the dining room service.