Cold Stone Creamery
Customize your ice cream with mix-ins folded on a frozen granite stone at this long-running Staten Island dessert spot.
- Mon – Thu, Sun, 12:00 – 22:00; Fri – Sat, 12:00 – 22:30
- $$
- 2341 Richmond Avenue
- 4.0 (245 reviews)
Description
Beyond the custom scoops, the menu features shakes, smoothies, and ice cream cakes. Choosing can take a minute given the sheer number of flavors, though staff are generally patient with the undecided. While the ice cream itself holds up, visits can be inconsistent, with some experiencing long wait times and hiccups in customer service under new ownership.