Heartland Bagels
A family-run Staten Island bakery serving fresh, kosher bagels, challah, and danishes baked daily for over 25 years.
- Mon – Fri, 06:00 – 19:00; Sat, 06:00 – 18:00; Sun, 06:00 – 15:00
- $
- 2311 Richmond Avenue
- 4.1 (462 reviews)
Description
This neighborhood spot centers on strictly kosher bagels under Rabbinical supervision, featuring classics like the everything bagel. While many visits are defined by quick service and staff who check your preferred doneness, the kitchen's execution can vary. Patrons report inconsistent toasting that sometimes runs burnt, alongside occasional long waits and light cream cheese spreads.
Good to know
Catering availableToasting can vary