Classic Staten Island Pies With Nearly Five Decades Behind Them

Staten Island has kept A and S Pizzeria family run for nearly 50 years, and the shop on Stuyvesant Place still treats the pie as the main event. The kitchen puts high quality ingredients behind every style, from traditional cheese and pan pies to Sicilian and Grandma style pizza for a table that wants a little of everything.

Pizza is only half the story. The menu stretches into Italian comfort food favorites, with subs, pasta, and classic entrees lined up next to the pies. That range makes it easy to split a pie and a pasta, or pair a sub with a pie for a group lunch.

Dine in, order delivery, or line up catering for a bigger gathering. Prices stay inexpensive, with the menu topping out just under 24 dollars, and the doors are open daily from 10 AM to 9 PM, which covers everything from an early lunch to a family dinner after work.