Carvel

This Staten Island location of the historic chain offers a clean space with indoor seating, a departure from the brand's usual focus on quick take-out. Alongside the standard menu, visitors can customize creations like the Reese's sundae dasher with triple brownie ice cream. Sticking to a specific craving can be tricky, however; finding specialty flavors like toasted marshmallow or sugar cookie is often a hit-or-miss prospect, and local feedback highlights highly variable customer service.