Pio Hot Bagels

4.2 (177)bakery

655 Rossville Ave

This Staten Island bakery serves fresh-baked bagels with a signature crispy crust and chewy center.

Get directions

Description

While the bagels are crafted with care rather than mass-produced—earning praise from locals and wedding guests alike—the shop draws mixed feedback. Customers frequently flag high prices for breakfast sandwiches, alongside concerns over order inaccuracies and customer service. For many, the high-quality bagels are the main draw, while the breakfast menu and counter service remain points of contention.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Order inaccuracies

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.