Caledonia Bar
A narrow Upper East Side pub with a cozy, dark-wood setting, an extensive whiskey selection, and a warm neighborhood vibe.
- Mon – Thu, 17:00 – 02:00 (+1); Fri – Sat, 16:00 – 04:00 (+1); Sun, 16:00 – 00:00 (+1)
- $$
- 1609 2nd Ave
- 4.6 (345 reviews)
People
AlanOwner
KevinOther
Description
Alongside tap beers, the menu features drinks like the High Priestess cocktail, Hot Toddy, and Dave Elly milk punch. Food options come with mixed reports: while older listings mention bar bites, visitors note the pub allows you to bring or order in outside food. The space also fills up for Scottish World Cup games, supported by a staff noted for quick service and attentive water refills.
Good to know
No food servedOutside food OK