Butterly Bakeshop

4.6 (150)bakery

263 Prospect Park West

This friendly Brooklyn bakery pairs creative custom cakes with soft, fresh treats like their popular s'mores cookie.

Get directions

Description

Beyond custom wedding cakes, the daily selection includes individual options like the lemon blueberry cake slice, which features a soft, muffin-like texture and a pleasant, not-overly-sweet lemon buttercream. While the shop is clean and welcoming, those seeking gluten-free cupcakes will find a more limited menu, with options like their dulce flavor. Delivery orders arrive in practical cake boxes that preserve the presentation.


Selected reviews


Good to know

Few gluten-free cupcakes

Also featured in

Ask Karpo for more information.