Butterfield Market

Beyond the curated specialty foods and baked goods, this historic neighborhood market draws a dedicated crowd for its customizable frozen yogurt. The froyo stands out for its smooth texture and flexible serving options, allowing you to order two unswirled flavors in a single small cup. While the yogurt itself earns high praise—especially flavors like peanut butter—the toppings menu is more modest, featuring around ten options that sometimes lean heavily on pistachio or run the risk of minor order mix-ups. For many, the best approach here is to skip the extras and stick to a simple, plain tart serving.