Most people arrive in Williamsburg at the Bedford Avenue L stop and never walk more than four blocks from it. That corridor is the most photographed and least interesting part of the neighbourhood: it turns over constantly, it prices for visitors, and the queue outside any given place is a poor guide to whether the food is good. The older Williamsburg is still here, mostly east and south of that strip — Italian families who never left, Puerto Rican counters along Graham Avenue, and a second generation of small kitchens that opened away from the rent. This is where to eat instead.
Several of these keep short or unusual hours, and a few close on the day you were planning to go. Tell Karpo in iMessage where you are standing in Williamsburg and it will tell you which of these is open right now and how far the walk actually is.
The Italian Williamsburg That Never Left
Before the neighbourhood became shorthand for something else, the northside and the area around Withers Street were solidly Italian, and a handful of those rooms are still running on the original terms. Bamonte's has been open since the turn of the last century and looks it in the best way: white tablecloths, waiters in jackets who have worked there for decades, red sauce that has not been reinterpreted. Order the pork chop with vinegar peppers or the linguine with clams, take cash, and do not expect the room to be impressed by you. Fortunato Brothers, on Manhattan Avenue near Devoe, is the pastry counter the restaurants send you to afterwards — espresso at the bar, cannoli filled to order, gelato in summer, and a room full of people who have been coming since the seventies. Napoli Bakery on Metropolitan is a bread bakery first, and the loaves come out of the oven hot in the afternoon for a couple of dollars. None of these three will show up on the average weekend itinerary, which is exactly why they are worth the ten-minute walk.
Graham Avenue and the Puerto Rican Side
Graham Avenue is co-named the Avenue of Puerto Rico, and the stretch between Metropolitan and Broadway is a different neighbourhood entirely from Bedford — bodegas with hot tables, bakeries selling quesitos and pan sobao, and small counters where a full plate of rice, beans and stewed chicken still lands under fifteen dollars. This is also where East Williamsburg's newer kitchens set up because the rent made sense: Win Son, on Graham near Montrose, does Taiwanese-American cooking that would be a destination anywhere else in the city, and its bakery across the street handles breakfast. The rule on this stretch is to look at the steam table rather than the sign. If the trays are full at two in the afternoon and there is a line of people who clearly work nearby, it is good.
The Southside and the Quiet Rooms
South of Grand Street the blocks get low and residential and the restaurants stop shouting. Marlow & Sons, under the Williamsburg Bridge on Broadway, has been running since the early 2000s and is still the most reliable dinner in the neighbourhood — a short menu, a dark front room, and a brick chicken that has not changed because it did not need to. La Superior on Berry Street does Mexico City street food at prices that predate the neighbourhood's reinvention. Samurai Mama on Grand serves udon in a converted wood-beamed space that is calmer at lunch than anything on Bedford is at any hour. And Best Pizza on Havemeyer, which is a takeaway slice shop with a wood oven and a white pie worth ordering, is the answer when the queue at the more famous places is around the block.
What to Order If You Only Get One Meal
If you have a single meal here and want it to taste like the neighbourhood rather than like a magazine, make it lunch rather than dinner and pick one of three things. A plate of red sauce in a room with tablecloths, because that version of Brooklyn is genuinely disappearing and the ones left are cooking the same food they were forty years ago. A cash-only counter plate on Graham Avenue with rice, beans and whatever the stew of the day is, eaten standing or at a two-top by the window. Or a slice and a coffee taken on a bench, which is what most people who actually live here do on a weekday. All three cost less than a coffee and a pastry on Wythe Avenue and tell you more about the place.
Practical Rules for Eating Here
Bring a card and a little cash: several of the older rooms still prefer cash, and one or two are cash-only outright. Check the day as much as the time — family-run kitchens here commonly close Mondays or Tuesdays, and the bakeries sell out of the good things by early afternoon. Walk east rather than north: five minutes inland from Bedford, prices drop by roughly a third for food that is often better. Weekend brunch on the northside is the single worst value in the neighbourhood, so if you are here on a Saturday morning, eat at a bakery counter instead and save the sit-down meal for the evening. And when the L is running badly, remember the J, M and Z at Marcy Avenue and the ferry at North Sixth Street; both put you within walking distance of everything above.
How to Spot the Real Ones
There is a reliable test for a neighbourhood that changes as fast as this one. Look at who is eating there at two in the afternoon on a weekday: if it is people from the surrounding blocks rather than people with tote bags and cameras, the place is anchored in the neighbourhood rather than in the internet. Look at the length of the menu, because the family kitchens here cook a dozen things properly and the newer rooms cook forty things adequately. Look at whether the sign has been repainted or merely maintained. And listen for the language behind the counter — Italian on Withers, Spanish on Graham, Mandarin and Polish scattered across the northside — which is the fastest way to work out whose cooking you are actually about to eat.
Tags: #Williamsburg #Brooklyn #NYC #HiddenGems #BedfordAvenue #GrahamAvenue #BrooklynEats #ItalianBrooklyn #NYCFood #NeighborhoodGuide #WhereToEat #EastWilliamsburg #SouthSide
Sources consulted: winsonbrooklyn.com · marlowandsons.com · nycgo.com · mta.info
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Hours at the family-run places move around, the bakeries sell out early, and a couple of these close on days that catch everyone out. Ask Karpo in iMessage which of these is open near you right now, what the wait looks like, and whether you need cash before you walk over.
