The top 5 pizzerias in NYC, if you ask the people who actually grew up eating here, are not clustered around SoHo or a Midtown corner with a forty-minute tourist queue. They sit at the far ends of subway lines — in Midwood, Bensonhurst, Howard Beach, the east Bronx, and Port Richmond — in rooms that have barely changed in half a century. This is a ride-out guide to five of them: Di Fara, L&B Spumoni Gardens, New Park, Louie & Ernie's, and Denino's, and to the small rituals that make each one worth the trip past the last stop you know.
Karpo lives in iMessage and treats a pizza pilgrimage like the logistics problem it is. Text it before you commit to the ride and it will check today's hours at all five counters, tell you exactly what to order at each one, and map the train-and-bus combo that gets you to Avenue J before the line forms.
Midwood, midday: the Di Fara ritual
On Avenue J, a few steps from the elevated tracks where the B and Q trains rattle above Midwood's brick rowhouses, the line outside Di Fara starts forming before the doors open. Nobody in it is in a hurry, because hurrying is beside the point. Domenico DeMarco opened this room in 1965 and made nearly every pie himself for over five decades; since his passing in 2022, his children have kept the operation in the family, working the same ovens at 1424 Avenue J. The room is small, the pace is deliberate, and a slice runs about five dollars — cheap tuition for watching pizza made the way almost nobody makes it anymore.
Watch the counter and you will see the ritual that built the reputation. Each pie comes out of the oven and gets finished by hand: a drizzle of olive oil, then fresh basil snipped directly over the cheese with scissors. That cheese is a blend — low-moisture mozzarella layered with imported fresh mozzarella and a dusting of grana padano — which is why the surface bubbles into browned, salty pools you do not get from a standard slice-shop pie. Regulars quietly ask for the square, which crisps harder at the edges. One warning: hours here are famously short and the shop pauses between lunch and dinner service, so confirm before you make the trek.
The Brooklyn counterweight: L&B Spumoni Gardens
Any honest ranking of the top 5 pizzerias in NYC has to reckon with Bensonhurst, where L&B Spumoni Gardens has been feeding 86th Street from its sprawl of picnic tables for generations. The order is the Sicilian square, built upside down: mozzarella laid directly on the dough, crushed tomato sauce spooned on top, so the crust bakes crisp instead of steaming soggy under cheese. The local move is to skip the sit-down room entirely — walk to the leftmost to-go window, order squares and a cup of the namesake spumoni, and eat outside with everyone else. The sauce lands sweet and bright, and the corner squares go first for a reason.
Why did the great pies end up out here? Old deck and brick ovens that never got ripped out, families that never sold the building, and neighborhood rents that let a modest slice business survive on volume and loyalty instead of tourist traffic. The outer boroughs did not preserve these places on purpose; they simply never forced them to change.
After dark in Queens and the Bronx
New Park Pizza has anchored Cross Bay Boulevard in Howard Beach since the 1950s, a low glass-walled hut that glows like a beacon at night and keeps serving until midnight. The brick oven runs hot, and the order that separates locals from drop-ins is two words: well done. Ask for it and your slice goes back in for extra minutes, coming out with charred, blistered edges and a crust that snaps instead of folds limp. It is a proper drive-or-A-train destination — Howard Beach is closer to JFK than to any tourist map — and that isolation is exactly why the room still feels like a neighborhood clubhouse.
In the east Bronx, Louie & Ernie's has worked the same corner at 1300 Crosby Avenue since 1947, turning out a thin, almost cracker-crisp pie in a space not much bigger than a living room. The sausage slice is the one people cross boroughs for, with fennel-flecked chunks that crisp at the edges. Two practical facts matter: the shop is cash only — there is an ATM on site, but save yourself the fee — and hours run shorter than Manhattan slice joints keep, so treat it as an early-evening stop off the 6 train rather than a late-night one.
The ferry pie: Denino's Pizzeria & Tavern
Port Richmond, Staten Island, is the deepest cut on this list and arguably the most rewarding. The room at 524 Port Richmond Avenue opened as a tavern in 1937; Carlo Denino started sliding pizzas out of the oven in 1951, and the bar-room thin crust he standardized is still the house style. Order the clam pie — garlic, parsley, olive oil, and grated cheese over fresh clams, no red sauce — or go the other direction with the garbage pie, a gleeful pile of sausage, meatball, pepperoni, and onion. Locals eat it in a wood-paneled dining room with a cold beer from the original bar, and the ferry-plus-bus journey is part of the experience.
Practical notes
Transit is straightforward if you plan one borough per outing: the B or Q to Avenue J for Di Fara, the D to Bensonhurst for L&B, the A toward Far Rockaway for Howard Beach's Q41 bus connection to New Park, the 6 to Pelham Bay Park then a short walk or bus for Louie & Ernie's, and the Staten Island Ferry plus the S44 or S59 bus for Denino's. Carry cash everywhere: Louie & Ernie's takes nothing else, and lines move faster with bills at the to-go windows. None of these rooms takes reservations — counter service and first-come tables are the rule. Weekday afternoons beat weekends by a wide margin, and New Park is your late option, serving until midnight while the others wind down much earlier. Double-check hours the same day; family-run shops close for holidays without notice.
Tags: #nycpizza #outerboroughs #brooklynpizza #difara #spumonigardens #newparkpizza #bronxfood #queenseats #statenislandpizza #midwood #bensonhurst #howardbeach #nycfoodie #slicelife
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Outer-borough pizza runs live and die on timing — short family-shop hours, oven pauses, a bus you did not know you needed. Ask Karpo for the latest word on the top 5 pizzerias in NYC's outer reaches, a borough-by-borough slice plan that fits your day, and a live route from your door to Avenue J or Cross Bay Boulevard before you head out.
