Ask ten New Yorkers to name the top 5 pizzerias in NYC and you will get ten different lists, because they are really arguing about styles, not shops. A blistered Neapolitan pie and a foldable dollar-fifty-era street slice are barely the same food. So this guide works like a decision tree: figure out what you want the crust to do, and it routes you to the one place in the city that does that exact thing at the highest level — from a Lower East Side tasting-counter Neapolitan to an upside-down Sicilian square deep in Bensonhurst.
Before you commit to a borough, let Karpo do the routing for you: text it your cravings and your starting point, and it maps all five styles by neighborhood, checks tonight's hours and wait times, and builds a crust-by-crust route in one message.
First, decide what you want the crust to do
Any ranking of the top 5 pizzerias in NYC is really five separate crowns, one per style — so here is the whole tree in one paragraph. If you want a puffy, leopard-spotted rim and a soft center that demands a fork, you want Neapolitan — go to Una Pizza Napoletana. If you want a thin, foldable slice eaten standing on a sidewalk at 2am, that is the classic New York style — go to Joe's Pizza. If your ideal bite is a crunchy, caramelized cheese edge on a fluffy square, that is Detroit-style — Emmy Squared. If you want a thick Sicilian square where the sauce sits proudly on top of the cheese, ride out to L&B Spumoni Gardens. And if you want to sit down with a razor-thin pie that breaks a few rules, book Rubirosa. Now, the details.
If you want blistered Neapolitan: Una Pizza Napoletana
At 175 Orchard Street on the Lower East Side, Anthony Mangieri has spent decades chasing a single idea: naturally leavened dough, a few flawless toppings, and a ferociously hot oven. Una Pizza Napoletana runs only Thursday through Saturday from 5pm, and each night ends when the dough does — Mangieri hand-shapes roughly 130 to 140 pies per service, judging the batch by feel. The marinara and margherita are the benchmarks; the crust arrives puffed, charred, and tangy from the slow fermentation.
Getting in is its own sport. Reservations open exactly two weeks ahead at 9:00 AM Eastern on OpenTable and are usually gone within about a minute. The workaround regulars use: a limited number of tables and bar seats are held for walk-ins, and the line for them starts forming around 4pm. Show up early, put your name down, and treat the wait as an excuse to wander Orchard Street.
If you want the foldable New York slice: Joe's Pizza
The classic slice is judged on structural engineering: thin enough to fold, sturdy enough not to flop, with sauce and mozzarella in perfect proportion. Joe's Pizza at 7 Carmine Street in Greenwich Village has been the reference standard since 1975, and it still behaves like an old-school counter joint — the Carmine Street original takes cash only, with an ATM conveniently parked right outside the door. It also keeps true New York hours, serving until 3am most nights and 4am on Fridays and Saturdays, which is exactly when a plain cheese slice tastes best.
If you want crispy frico edges: Emmy Squared
Detroit-style is the inverse of Neapolitan: a rectangular pan pie with a fluffy, focaccia-like interior and edges of frico — cheese that caramelizes against the steel pan into a crackly amber crust — finished with racing stripes of sauce. Emmy Squared brought the style to New York and now runs several city locations, including 83 First Avenue in the East Village and outposts in Park Slope, Hell's Kitchen, and the Upper East Side. Order the Emmy, a white pie with banana peppers, red onion, and ranch, and fight for the corner pieces; they carry frico on two sides, and the kitchen even sells a corner slice on its own because demand is that specific.
If you want the upside-down Sicilian square: L&B Spumoni Gardens
The Sicilian square at L&B Spumoni Gardens, at 2725 86th Street in Bensonhurst, is built upside-down: deli-sliced mozzarella goes directly onto the dough, the tangy-sweet sauce is spread over the cheese, and a dusting of pecorino finishes the top. The result is a caramelized underside, a fluffy crumb, and sauce that hits your palate first. The operation dates to 1939 and still works best as a takeout ritual — head straight to the leftmost to-go window for pizza, carry your tray to a picnic table, and finish with the house spumoni, a striped scoop of chocolate, vanilla, and pistachio. Locals skip the tiny lot and hunt for street parking instead.
If you want a sit-down pie that bends the rules: Rubirosa
Rubirosa, at 235 Mulberry Street in Nolita, serves a razor-thin, cracker-crisp crust built on the Pappalardo family recipe — a hybrid that is neither Neapolitan nor street slice, and the reason the dining room is packed daily from 11am to 11pm. The signature is the tie-dye pie, swirled with vodka sauce, pesto, and fresh mozzarella. Plan ahead: tables book out on Resy, and walking in without a strategy can mean a two-to-three-hour wait. The reliable move is arriving right at the 11am open on a weekday, when the room is calm and the first pies come out fast.
Practical notes
Hitting all of the top 5 pizzerias in NYC takes planning, and transit beats driving for every one of them. Take the F to Second Avenue for Una Pizza Napoletana, any West 4th Street line for Joe's, the 6 to Spring Street for Rubirosa, and the D toward Coney Island for L&B Spumoni Gardens in Bensonhurst; Emmy Squared's East Village shop is a short walk from the F or L. Bring cash for Joe's — the Carmine Street counter does not take cards — while the others accept plastic. Timing matters most at Una (Thursday to Saturday only, from 5pm, reservations two weeks out on OpenTable) and Rubirosa (book on Resy or arrive at open). L&B runs long hours daily, roughly 11am to 11:30pm, and Joe's serves into the small hours, so sequence your day from hardest door to easiest.
Tags: #nycpizza #top5pizzerias #pizzatour #neapolitanpizza #detroitstylepizza #sicilianpizza #nycfood #brooklynfood #joespizza #rubirosa #emmysquared #unapizzanapoletana #lbspumonigardens #nycfoodie
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Want to know whether the walk-in line at Una has already formed, which Emmy Squared location has corner slices left, or if the L&B windows are worth the ride today? Ask Karpo for the latest updates on the top 5 pizzerias in NYC, a crust-by-crust day plan, and a live route across Manhattan and Brooklyn before you head out.
