There are two entirely different things sharing the word tiki in New York, and telling them apart before you go out saves an evening. One is a decorating decision: bamboo, a thatched overhang, a menu of sweet drinks poured fast. The other is a rum programme — a bar that has spent years building a back shelf of aged Jamaican and Demerara rums and treats a Mai Tai as a cocktail with three moving parts rather than a novelty. The second kind is what people mean when they say New York got good at this, and it is concentrated in Brooklyn.
These rooms are small, most of them do not take reservations, and the difference between arriving at seven and arriving at nine is an hour on the pavement. Tell Karpo which night you are going out and which borough you are starting in, and get which rooms are open, what the wait looks like at that hour, and a second option four minutes away.
Sunken Harbor Club is the one to understand first
It sits up a creaky staircase above Gage & Tollner, the Downtown Brooklyn steakhouse that first opened in 1879, which is already a strange enough setting. The bar began as a pop-up in 2013 and took the room permanently in 2021, and Garret Richard's drinks list is where the city's current tropical style largely comes from — layered, dry rather than sugary, and built on specific rums rather than a generic blend. Expect names like the Planter's Potion, which runs Jamaican rums against assam tea and spiced lime.
The mechanics matter as much as the drinks. There are no reservations, the room is small, and it is popular. The people who get in without waiting are the ones standing at the bottom of the stairs before it opens. That is not a secret, it is just a discipline most people are unwilling to observe on a Friday.
Prospect Heights runs the neighbourhood version
Shaka Shaka Tiki in Prospect Heights makes the case for the other model — a compact room that serves coffee and light food during the day and turns into a glowing tropical bar after dark. It is less austere than the Downtown Brooklyn rooms and much easier to get into on a weeknight, and the drinks are properly made rather than decorative. If you want the genre without the queue, this is the version to start with.
What separates a rum bar from a tiki bar
Ask to see the rum list. A serious room will have one, organised by island and by style, and the bartender will happily talk you through the difference between a pot-still Jamaican and a Spanish-style column rum. A room that hands you a laminated menu of six sweet drinks and no rum list is not doing the same thing, which is fine on a hot Tuesday and disappointing if you came for the craft. Neither is better. They are simply different evenings and cost about the same.
September is the right month for this
Frozen and tropical drinks in New York are seasonal in a way locals feel and visitors do not. The last genuinely warm evenings run through September, and rooftop and patio service starts thinning by early October. If there is a tropical drink you want to have outdoors in this city this year, the window is now rather than later, and the rooms know it — a lot of the best frozen programmes run hardest in exactly these few weeks.
How to drink these without losing the night
Tropical drinks are stronger than they taste, because the whole technique is built on hiding rum behind citrus and spice. Two well-made ones is a full evening for most people. The other habit worth having: order the bartender's choice on the second drink. In rooms with lists this deep, the second drink chosen for you is almost always better than the second drink chosen by you, and it is how you find the bottle you did not know to ask for.
What to do while you wait
Since the best of these rooms do not take reservations, the wait is part of the plan rather than an accident, and Downtown Brooklyn and Prospect Heights both reward it. The sensible pattern is to put your name in if the room takes names, eat properly somewhere nearby, and come back — a full dinner beforehand also changes how three rum drinks land. If the room does not take names at all, the only reliable technique is to arrive at opening, which on a Thursday is much less of an imposition than it sounds and gets you the best seats in the house for the price of being early.
Practical notes
Sunken Harbor Club, above Gage & Tollner in Downtown Brooklyn, is the reference room — no reservations, small, arrive before it opens. Shaka Shaka Tiki in Prospect Heights is the easier weeknight version. Ask for the rum list to tell a rum bar from a themed one. Two drinks is a night. The warm-evening window closes in early October, so outdoor tropical drinking is a September project rather than an autumn one.
Tags: #TikiBars #RumBars #NYCBars #Brooklyn #CocktailBars #SunkenHarborClub #ProspectHeights #NYCNightlife #TropicalCocktails #BarsAndNights #NewYorkCity #NYCWeekend #NYCGuide
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Want to know which rum rooms are open tonight, how long the wait is at the hour you are going, and where to go four minutes away if the stairs are full? Ask Karpo for the current list by neighbourhood and a plan that gets you a seat.
