What Happens at 10:55 p.m. on Tony Sunday
The Tony Awards run from 8 to 11 p.m. on the second Sunday of June every year — June 14 for 2026. The ceremony is at Radio City Music Hall on Sixth Avenue and 50th. The official after-party is at the Plaza. But the actual ritual — the one that happens whether the producers ordered it or not — is the eight-block walk south to 44th Street and the brass-and-glass door of Sardi's.
Sardi's opens at noon. On Tony Sunday it stays open until two in the morning. The reservations book for the night of the ceremony fills six months before. The room — main dining room on the second floor, oak-paneled, walls covered in eight hundred framed caricatures — does not change for the occasion. The cannelloni is the cannelloni. The crew is the crew. The room is the same room a Tony winner has walked into every year since the awards began in 1947.
What's different that one night: a meaningful fraction of the room is holding a Tony Award.
Why This Restaurant
Vincent Sardi opened Sardi's in 1921 at 246 West 44th, then moved it to 234 West 44th in 1927 when the original building was demolished for the St. James Theatre. The current building has been Sardi's for ninety-nine years. The building is on the same block as four working theaters: the St. James, the Helen Hayes, the Majestic, and (across the street) the Shubert. Half the cast of any Broadway show in performance can be at a table at Sardi's within five minutes of the curtain coming down.
The caricatures came in 1927 too. Vincent Sardi commissioned Russian-born artist Alex Gard to draw the regulars in exchange for two free meals a day. Gard drew seven hundred caricatures over twenty-two years. After his death the practice continued under other illustrators, and the wall now holds roughly thirteen hundred frames, with about eight hundred currently hung. To get on the wall you have to be drawn by the house illustrator — by tradition, you find out you're on the wall when someone tells you. The illustrators draw, the management hangs, the subject is the last to know.
The Tony Awards itself was launched in 1947 in the Waldorf-Astoria ballroom, named for actress and producer Antoinette Perry. Sardi's was the post-ceremony stop from year one.
What to Order on Tony Sunday
The cannelloni au gratin is the dish people order on Tony night. House-made pasta, beef and veal filling, béchamel, baked. It has been on the menu since 1927 and is the version Vincent Sardi senior considered his definitive contribution to Italian-American cooking in New York. Order it.
Other defaults that work for the late hour: steak Diane (carved tableside if the room is calm), shrimp scampi, the chopped salad. The bar makes a serviceable Manhattan and a tradition-quality vodka martini. The wine list is deep on Italian. The dessert that staff push on Tony night is the cheesecake — solid, not a destination.
If you are not seated until after midnight, the small upstairs bar has its own menu and stays open later than the main room. Bar seats are first-come; reservation status does not transfer.
How to Actually Get In
Tony night reservations on the main floor go to industry. The book opens roughly six months in advance. By January it is gone. If you did not book by January, your three real options are: the bar upstairs (walk-in, no reservation, the air is the same air, the caricatures are the same caricatures), a pre-Tonys early seating (5:30 to 7 p.m. — you'll miss the room's full population but you will see Sardi's), or a post-midnight walk-in for the late table turnover, which sometimes opens up after 12:30 a.m. when industry parties shift to the Plaza.
The dress code is loosely enforced — sport jacket and collared shirt for men is the default, equivalent for women. People dress for the night. You can be slightly underdressed in a restaurant where half the room is in formal wear; you cannot be in a t-shirt.
What You Are Actually There to See
Sardi's on Tony Sunday is one of the few rooms in New York where a stranger walking in with a literal trophy is the same as a Wednesday lunch — the room has been doing this for seventy-nine years. The waiters do not stare. The room registers the win, the room moves on, the cannelloni arrives. The dignity of the place is its refusal to break form for a Tony any more than it broke form for a Pulitzer or a Nobel or the cast of South Pacific in 1949 walking in after the eight o'clock curtain.
What you are watching is the only continuous Broadway custom older than the awards themselves. The awards were invented in 1947. The custom they walked into existed in 1947.
If You Are Going Any Other Night in 2026
Tony Sunday is the loudest night. The cleanest night to actually experience Sardi's is a Wednesday matinee day at 5:30 p.m. — the restaurant fills with theatergoers crossing from a 2 p.m. matinee to an 8 p.m. evening show. The room is busy, lit, alive, and you can get a window table on a week's notice.
Pre-show at 6 p.m. on any performance night is also good — turn the bar into your first drink, eat lightly, walk five minutes to your theater. Show-flippers, costume-shop runners, and actors moonlighting as servers populate the bar after 11:30 p.m. on most nights. The caricatures stay where they are.
Practical notes
- Address: Sardi's, 234 West 44th Street, between Broadway and 8th Avenue, New York, NY 10036.
- Tony Sunday 2026: June 14. Reservations for main dining room open December 2025 and gone by January.
- Hours: lunch noon-3pm, dinner 5pm-midnight on most nights; Tony Sunday extended to 2am.
- Getting there: 1/2/3/7/N/Q/R/W to Times Square-42nd Street, walk two blocks north on 7th Ave, one block east on 44th.
- Order: cannelloni au gratin (1927 recipe). Steak Diane if tableside service is moving. Vodka martini at the bar.
- If no main-floor reservation: walk in to the upstairs bar — first-come, same caricatures, no reservation needed.
- Dress: jacket and collared shirt for men, equivalent for women. No formalwear required but no t-shirts.
The point
Most Tony Awards after-parties are sponsorships — a corporation rents a hotel ballroom, books a DJ, and assembles a guest list. Sardi's is the opposite. It is a restaurant that has been at 234 West 44th since 1927 and has been the post-Tony stop since the awards began in 1947, not because anyone arranged it, but because the room was already there and so were the people. The cannelloni is the same cannelloni. The wall is the same wall. The award is what's new.
Tags: #sardis #tonyawards #broadway #timessquare #manhattantheater #44thstreet #vincentsardi #rightontime #karpofinds #broadwaytraditions #nycdining #cannelloni #theaterdistrict #post-tonys #vintagenyc
Sources consulted: sardis.com · tonyawards.com · en.wikipedia.org · nytimes.com · broadway.org
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
