Pizza near me in San Francisco produces a ranked list that mixes two completely different products under one heading. There is the slice window, which is a transaction of about ninety seconds, and there is the sit-down pizzeria, which is a ninety-minute booking with a wine list. Both are excellent here. Neither is a substitute for the other, and almost every bad pizza decision in this city comes from searching for one and ending up in the other.
The wait at the good sit-down rooms and the queue at the good windows move in completely different ways. Ask Karpo which format is right for tonight and what the wait actually is before you walk over.
North Beach runs both economies on one street
The two blocks around Stockton and Green in North Beach contain the clearest illustration of the split in the city. Tony's Pizza Napoletana at 1570 Stockton Street is the sit-down end: Tony Gemignani won the World Pizza Cup in Naples in 2007 with a Margherita, and the restaurant runs multiple ovens at different temperatures so that it can produce more than a dozen distinct regional styles under one roof.
The detail that governs a visit there is the Margherita limit. The classic Neapolitan Margherita is made only in the wood-fired oven held at around nine hundred degrees, and the kitchen makes a strictly limited number per day — the traditional cap is seventy-three. When they are gone they are gone, regardless of how long you waited or what you are willing to pay. If that is the pizza you came for, arrive early in service, not late.
A short walk away, Golden Boy Pizza on Green Street is the other economy entirely: square Sicilian slices sold from a counter, a handful of stools, no reservations, no table, no wait to speak of. It has been doing the same thing since the 1970s and the clam and garlic square is the order people come back for.
The sit-down rooms worth booking
Del Popolo at 855 Bush Street began life as a wood-fired oven built into a shipping container on the back of a truck, which is still one of the better origin stories in American pizza, and now occupies a permanent room with a full bar. The dough is the point and the room is quiet enough to have a conversation in, which is rarer in this category than it should be.
Little Star built its reputation on a cornmeal-crust deep dish and has locations on Divisadero and in the Mission. The thing to know is a timing constraint: deep dish takes a long time in the oven by design, so it is a poor choice if anyone at the table is in a hurry or under seven years old. The thin crust at the same restaurants is excellent and arrives in a quarter of the time.
Detroit-style — thick, rectangular, cheese caramelised against the edge of the pan — has become the city's most-improved category over the last few years, with the strongest versions in SoMa and Bernal Heights. It sits between the two economies: too substantial to eat standing up, quick enough that a table is not really necessary.
The slice windows
Beyond Golden Boy, the slice economy runs across the Mission, the Haight, the Marina and the corridor around the clubs in SoMa, and it peaks at hours the sit-down rooms are closed. A slice window at eleven on a Saturday night is not competing with a pizzeria, it is competing with a taqueria, and the honest way to judge it is on speed, price and whether the slice survives being carried a block.
Arizmendi on Valencia Street is the outlier worth knowing about: a worker-owned cooperative bakery that makes exactly one pizza a day, always vegetarian, with the toppings changing daily and posted rather than chosen. You cannot customise it and there is no menu to browse. It is sold by the slice or the whole, it sells out, and it is one of the few genuinely distinctive pizza propositions in San Francisco.
Which format for which night
Decide by constraint, not by craving. If you have more than an hour and fewer than six people, a sit-down room gives you the best pizza in the city and it is not close. If you have twenty minutes, a slice window gives you eighty percent of the quality for a fifth of the effort. If you have a group of eight, order whole pies for collection rather than trying to seat everyone — nearly every good pizzeria in San Francisco is better at making pizza than at seating a party. And if it is after eleven, the sit-down question is moot and the only live option is a window.
Reheating, which decides half your pizza experiences
Most pizza is eaten some time after it left the oven, and almost everybody reheats it wrong. A microwave steams the crust and produces something soft and grey. An oven takes fifteen minutes and dries the cheese. The correct method takes four minutes: a dry pan over a medium heat, lid on for the last ninety seconds with a teaspoon of water flicked in beside the slice, which steams the top while the base crisps. It restores a deck-oven slice almost completely. It will not save a Neapolitan pizza, because nothing will — that pizza was a four-minute window and the window closed. Knowing which of the two you have in the box is worth more than any reheating trick.
Practical notes
Tony's Pizza Napoletana, 1570 Stockton St, North Beach: multiple ovens at different temperatures for more than a dozen regional styles; Tony Gemignani won the World Pizza Cup in Naples in 2007; the Neapolitan Margherita is made only in the roughly 900-degree wood oven and capped at 73 per day, so arrive early in service. Golden Boy Pizza, Green St, North Beach: square Sicilian slices from a counter, stools only, minimal wait, clam and garlic is the signature. Del Popolo, 855 Bush St: started as a wood oven in a shipping container on a truck, now a quiet room with a full bar. Little Star on Divisadero and in the Mission: cornmeal-crust deep dish takes a long bake — order thin crust if time matters. Detroit-style is strongest in SoMa and Bernal Heights. Arizmendi on Valencia St: worker-owned co-op making one vegetarian pizza a day, toppings posted not chosen, sells out. For groups of eight or more, order whole pies for collection rather than seeking a table.
Tags: #PizzaNearMe #SanFrancisco #TonysPizzaNapoletana #GoldenBoyPizza #DelPopolo #LittleStar #Arizmendi #NorthBeach #MissionDistrict #DetroitStyle #SliceWindow #SFEats #Neapolitan #BayAreaFood
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Pizza in San Francisco is a format decision before it is a quality one, and the good ovens run out of the good pizza. Ask Karpo which rooms near you have a table tonight, whether the Margherita count at the North Beach ovens is still live, and which slice window is open if the answer is no.
