There is a bar on Prospect Park West that has been open since 1933 and still serves its beer in thirty-two-ounce containers. Not pitchers, not steins — containers, which is what they are called inside the building and what you should call them if you want to order one without a conversation. Farrell's Bar & Grill in Windsor Terrace is not a sports bar in any modern sense. It is a bar that has had games on for ninety years, which is a different and better thing.
Old neighbourhood bars are the best places to watch a big game and the hardest to get information about — no website, no posted hours, no reservations. Ask Karpo which long-standing rooms near you will have the game on tonight and roughly how busy they get.
1933, and what that date means
Farrell's opened in 1933, the year Prohibition ended, with Eddie Farrell credited as the man who established it. That date is worth sitting with for a second. It means this room opened its doors in the first legal month American bars had in over a decade, in a Brooklyn neighbourhood that was then mostly Irish, and it has been serving continuously since. Almost nothing else in the borough can say that.
The sign says Bar & Grill, which was standard for the period and is now slightly misleading — it functions as a bar rather than a restaurant, and you should eat before you come. The clientele over the decades has run heavily to firefighters, police officers and local writers, and the visitor list includes Harvey Keitel, Peter Weller, Jimmy Breslin, Pete Hamill and Congressman Peter King. That is a particular kind of room: one where the famous people who came were mostly the ones who were from there anyway.
The container, and the foam ban
The signature is very cold beer served in a thirty-two-ounce container. For most of the bar's life that container was styrofoam, which sounds like a downgrade and functions as the opposite — foam holds cold far better than glass, and a beer that needs to survive being drunk slowly while standing up benefits enormously from the insulation. When New York City restricted foam products, Farrell's switched to paper or plastic and kept the format.
This is the practical thing to understand before you order. A container is not a drink you sip while checking your phone. It is a commitment of roughly three standard beers, in one vessel, and the room's entire social rhythm is built around it — people stand, they hold the container, they talk, and they are there for a while. Ordering two is a decision about your evening, not about your thirst.
The history that the bar does not advertise
For much of its early existence Farrell's did not serve women at the bar itself; women were seated in the rear of the room. That changed, and some sources credit the actress Shirley MacLaine as the first unaccompanied woman served at the bar. It is the sort of fact that a bar with a marketing department would either bury or turn into a plaque, and Farrell's has done neither, which is roughly in character.
Mentioning it is not a knock on the place. It is context for why the room feels the way it does. Bars that survive ninety years do so by changing slowly and under protest, and the texture you are enjoying is the accumulated residue of exactly that stubbornness.
Why the beer is colder than it should be
The thing regulars mention first is not the history, it is the temperature. Farrell's beer is served extremely cold, colder than most bars bother with, and the container is part of why it stays that way. A pint glass sitting on a warm bar top in a crowded room loses its edge in about ten minutes. Thirty-two ounces of very cold beer in an insulated vessel, held in your hand rather than set down, is still cold at the bottom — which is the only reason a drink that size makes any sense at all.
It also explains a habit that looks odd to newcomers. People hold the container rather than resting it, and they stand rather than sit, and the two things are related. The format dictates the posture, and the posture is what makes the room feel like a room rather than a set of tables. If you come in and immediately look for somewhere to put your drink down, you have slightly missed the point.
How to use it in October
Windsor Terrace sits on the southwestern edge of Prospect Park, which makes this a neighbourhood destination rather than a citywide one. For a playoff game that is the advantage: you are not competing with people who came from Manhattan, because they did not. The room will be full of people who live within fifteen blocks, which is the correct population for watching baseball in a bar.
Two pieces of etiquette. First, this is a standing bar, so do not arrive as a group of eight expecting a table. Second, the television situation is modest by design — a screen or two, not a wall — so get somewhere with a sightline early rather than assuming you can drift. If you want a sofa and eleven angles on the replay, this is emphatically the wrong room and you should be delighted that it still exists anyway.
Practical notes
Farrell's Bar & Grill, 215 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn, NY 11215, in Windsor Terrace on the southwestern edge of Prospect Park. Open since 1933. Beer served in 32-ounce containers, formerly styrofoam and now paper or plastic following New York City's foam restrictions. It operates as a bar rather than a grill — eat beforehand. Standing room rather than table service; arrive early for a sightline on a big game. Nearest subway is Fort Hamilton Parkway or 15th Street-Prospect Park on the F and G. Cash habits and opening hours at rooms of this age are not reliably published anywhere, so call ahead or ask a local before making a long trip.
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
Tags: #watchmlbplayoffsnearme #farrellsbar #windsorterrace #brooklynbars #prospectpark #mlbplayoffs #october #brooklynhistory #nycbars #divebar #baseballnyc #watchparty #southbrooklyn #oldnewyork
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Bars that have been open since the 1930s work on habit rather than policy, and almost nothing about them is written down. Ask Karpo what is actually open near you tonight, whether the room will have your game on, and which nearby alternative has table seating if standing at a rail is not the plan.
