Search for the top 5 pizzerias in NYC and you get a ranking. What you rarely get is the part that decides whether you actually eat: when the waitlist opens, whether the register takes a card, which night the kitchen closes early, and how long the train really takes to get there. New York has far more great pizza than any list can hold, so the more useful question is not which five are objectively best. It is which five are worth rearranging an evening around, and what you need to know before you commit to the trip.
Tell Karpo which borough you're starting from and how long you're willing to wait, and it will pick the pizzeria that still has a realistic table tonight.
The five below are the ones New Yorkers genuinely queue for, and each one asks something different of you. One wants you standing on a Carroll Gardens sidewalk before most people have finished work. One wants a calendar reminder two weeks out. One will simply let you walk in at nine o'clock at night. They are listed roughly by how much planning they demand, from the most demanding to the most forgiving, with the operational details that trip visitors up.
Lucali, Carroll Gardens — the four o'clock ritual
Lucali sits at 575 Henry Street in Carroll Gardens, in a room lit largely by candles, and it has never made getting in easy. The kitchen serves from 5 p.m., the room is closed on Tuesdays, and the host starts taking waitlist names at 4 p.m. In practice the line on the sidewalk forms earlier than that, often around half past three on a weekend, because everyone in it knows the same thing: the list fills in one pass and there is no second chance later in the evening.
Two rules matter more than the ranking. Lucali is cash only, and it is BYOB. Arriving with a card and no bottle is the single most common way to lose a table you already waited an hour for. There is no slice service either — pies are whole, and the menu is deliberately short.
The waiting time is not dead time if you plan for it. Once your name is down you are usually given a rough return window, which is enough to walk up to Court Street for a bottle, or to sit somewhere nearby until the text comes. Treat the gap as part of the evening rather than an obstacle, and the whole thing becomes pleasant instead of punishing.
- Address: 575 Henry Street, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
- Closed Tuesdays; service from 5 p.m.
- Cash only, BYOB, whole pies only
- Put your name down at 4 p.m., expect the sidewalk line earlier
L'Industrie, Williamsburg — the one with no timing game
L'Industrie at 254 South 2nd Street is the counterweight to Lucali. It is open every day from noon to 10 p.m., which makes it the only entry on this list you can decide on at the last minute. It also happens to be the reason the phrase best pizza slice keeps getting attached to Brooklyn: the shop took first place in 50 Top Pizza's slice ranking, and its prosciutto and burrata slice is the one people photograph.
There is still a line, but it is a moving line rather than a waiting list. Because the format is a counter rather than a dining room, the queue tends to look worse than it is; a group of fifteen people can clear in ten or fifteen minutes. The trade-off is seating, which is limited and informal. Most people eat standing, or take the slices to the benches nearby.
If you only have one pizza-shaped evening in New York and no appetite for logistics, this is the answer. It is also the sensible fallback when a plan built around one of the harder venues collapses, since it stays open later than most of the others.
Una Pizza Napoletana, Lower East Side — a reservation, not a line
Una Pizza Napoletana operates on a different model altogether. It opens Thursday through Saturday only, and it releases reservations two weeks ahead at 9 a.m. Walk-ins are accepted for drinks and dessert but not for a full sit-down meal, which means turning up hopeful on a Friday night is not a strategy. This is the room that 50 Top Pizza has named the best pizzeria in the United States, so the tables do not linger.
The practical version of this is simple: work out the date you want, count back fourteen days, and set an alarm for a few minutes before nine. Booking is a two-minute job if you are ready and an impossible one if you are not. If the date you want is gone, check again in the days that follow, because cancellations do surface.
Because it is only open three days a week, this is the one venue on the list that should anchor your plan rather than fit around it. Choose the pizza night first, then build the rest of the evening in the surrounding blocks.
Totonno's, Coney Island — go before the dough runs out
Totonno's has been at 1524 Neptune Avenue since the 1920s, and it still bakes in a coal oven. It runs Thursday through Sunday, it is cash only, and — the detail that catches people out — it closes when the dough runs out. That is not a figure of speech. If the day has been busy, the doors shut early regardless of what the posted hours say.
The consequence is that Totonno's rewards lunch far more than dinner. Arriving early in the afternoon on a Thursday or Friday gives you a good chance of a table and a full menu; arriving at seven on a Sunday in summer does not. It is the longest journey on this list, so it is also the one where an early close hurts most.
The upside is that the trip has a natural shape. Coney Island's boardwalk and the beach are a short walk away, which turns a pizza run into an afternoon rather than a meal with a long commute attached to either end.
Di Fara, Midwood — check the day before you ride out
Di Fara at 1424 Avenue J in Midwood is the most storied address here. Domenico DeMarco built its reputation over decades and made every pie himself; since his death in 2022 the shop has continued under new ownership, and the Di Fara name now also appears on delivery-only kitchens elsewhere in the city. The Avenue J original is the one people mean.
The scheduling detail worth knowing is uneven: the shop runs to 8 p.m. most days, but on Mondays it shuts at 5 p.m. Since this is a forty-minute ride from Manhattan on the Q, arriving at six on a Monday is a genuinely wasted evening. Check the hours the day before, not on the platform.
Go for the whole pie rather than the slice if you have the group for it, and treat the surrounding stretch of Avenue J as part of the visit. It is a working neighbourhood shopping street rather than a destination block, which is a large part of the appeal.
Practical notes
All five reward a phone call or a quick hours check on the day. Lucali and Totonno's are cash only; L'Industrie and Di Fara take cards. Only L'Industrie is open seven days a week, and only Una Pizza Napoletana requires a booking made in advance. Travel times are the hidden cost: Coney Island and Midwood are both meaningful rides from Manhattan, so pair them with something else in south Brooklyn rather than treating them as a quick detour. If you are assembling a group, whole-pie venues suit four or more people, while a slice counter is the better call for two. And if a first choice falls through, the fallback should be geographic — pick the next option on the same subway line rather than the next one on the ranking.
Tags: #nycpizza #top5pizzerias #bestpizzanyc #lucali #lindustrie #unapizzanapoletana #totonnos #difara #brooklynpizza #carrollgardens #williamsburg #coneyisland #nycfood #nycrestaurants
Sources consulted: 50toppizza.it · lucali.com · timeout.com · en.wikipedia.org
Please drink responsibly. Must be of legal drinking age.
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Want to know which of these is realistically open tonight, how long the wait is running, and whether you need cash before you leave the house? Ask Karpo for current hours across the five, a pizzeria matched to the borough you are starting from, and a nearby fallback if the waitlist has already closed.
