The Geography of Divided Loyalties
When the Cavaliers vs Knicks second round series tips off, the usual tribal lines blur in unexpected corners of Manhattan and the Bronx. Five bars across New York City have cultivated oddly fervent Cleveland followings, drawing transplants, contrarians, and Donovan Mitchell devotees into wood-paneled rooms where wine-and-gold banners hang beside Midtown skyscraper shadows. These are not neutral sports bars hedging their bets with every team logo. They are committed, occasionally bewildering outposts of Lake Erie loyalty in a city that bleeds orange and blue.
The NBA playoffs second round amplifies the strangeness. Knicks fans expect home-court advantage everywhere from Penn Station to Astoria, yet walk into certain Hell's Kitchen pierogi joints or Midtown East basement taverns and the crowd erupts when Cleveland scores. The phenomenon speaks to New York's endless capacity for micro-communities, where a single bartender from Shaker Heights or a manager who spent a college semester in Columbus can transform a forty-seat room into enemy territory for the home team.
The Midtown East Transplant Tavern
Tucked below street level on East 47th Street between Second and Third Avenues, a narrow tavern with exposed brick and a single flat-screen television has flown a Cavaliers pennant since 2018. The owner, a Cleveland native who relocated for a finance job two decades ago, never abandoned his Rust Belt allegiances. During the regular season the bar serves a mixed clientele of Murray Hill office workers and UN diplomats grabbing after-work pints. But when Cleveland plays New York in any sport, the room tilts decisively toward the visitors.
On game nights the tavern enforces an unwritten dress code: wine-and-gold gear earns you a seat at the bar, while Knicks jerseys relegate you to standing room near the restrooms. The bartender, a transplant from Lakewood, keeps a laminated photo of the 2016 championship parade taped to the cash register. The kitchen serves Cincinnati-style chili and pierogies, a nod to Ohio's overlapping foodways. It is a forty-seat time capsule where the second round feels less like hostile territory and more like a road game with a cheering section.
Hell's Kitchen Pierogi Room
On Ninth Avenue near 52nd Street, a Polish restaurant with a back room dedicated to Cleveland sports memorabilia draws a nightly crowd of Cavaliers faithful. The connection is historical rather than geographic: the owner's uncle played minor-league baseball in Akron during the 1980s and never stopped following Ohio teams. The back room, accessible through a narrow hallway past the kitchen, seats twenty-four and features framed photos of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, a signed Donovan Mitchell jersey, and a neon Cavaliers logo that hums above the bar.
The pierogi menu offers sixteen varieties, including a Cleveland-inspired kielbasa-and-kraut filling that regulars order by the dozen during NBA playoffs games. The room books up days in advance for second round matchups, with a waitlist managed via a clipboard at the host stand. No reservations, no phone calls, just names scribbled in ballpoint pen. The atmosphere is part sports bar, part supper club, with strangers sharing tables and arguing defensive rotations over plates of fried dough and sour cream.
The Bronx Donovan Mitchell Shrine Corner
In the Fordham neighborhood, a sports bar on Webster Avenue has dedicated its northeast corner to Donovan Mitchell memorabilia. The shrine began as a joke when the star guard was traded to Cleveland, but the bar's manager, a lifelong Knicks fan with a contrarian streak, leaned into the bit. Now the corner features a life-size cardboard cutout, a looping highlight reel on a dedicated monitor, and a guest book where patrons write messages of support or trash talk depending on their allegiance.
The bar itself remains Knicks territory, but the corner has become a pilgrimage site for Cavaliers fans scattered across the Bronx. On game nights a fragile truce holds: Knicks supporters occupy the main room and the long bar, while Cleveland faithful cluster in the corner beneath the cutout. The manager referees disputes and occasionally buys a round for whichever side is losing by more than fifteen points. It is democracy by geography, a thirty-square-foot DMZ where the second round series plays out in miniature.
Murray Hill's Accidental Outpost
A wine bar on Lexington Avenue near 35th Street stumbled into Cleveland fandom by accident. Three years ago a group of Ohio State alumni began gathering for weekend games, and the bar's owner, charmed by their loyalty and reliable tabs, started stocking Great Lakes Brewing Company beer and playing Cleveland sports radio between sets of jazz. The wine bar aesthetic, exposed brick and Edison bulbs and small plates, clashes wonderfully with the Cavaliers flags now draped over the back booth.
The clientele remains majority wine-sipping professionals, but game nights transform the space. The owner dims the lights, turns up the volume, and the back half of the room becomes a raucous celebration of mid-major Midwest basketball. The front half continues serving Pinot Noir and charcuterie boards, a surreal split-screen of New York nightlife. During the NBA playoffs the bar requires a ten-dollar cover for the back room, which includes a drink ticket and access to a buffet of Ohio comfort food: buckeye candies, Cincinnati chili dip, and soft pretzels with stadium mustard.
Practical Notes for the Second Round
Navigating these bars during a heated Cavaliers vs Knicks series requires strategy and flexibility. Most do not take reservations, and lines form an hour before tip-off. Arriving early secures a seat but commits you to a three-hour stay. Dress codes are informal but politically charged: neutral gear is safest for first-time visitors, though wearing Knicks colors into a Cleveland bar guarantees attention, not all of it friendly. Cash is king at the smaller venues, and ATMs are scarce.
- Arrive sixty to ninety minutes before game time to secure seating at smaller venues
- Bring cash for bars without card minimums or reliable wireless readers
- Respect house allegiances; heckling is tolerated but physical altercations end in ejection
- Check social media day-of for last-minute closures or private event bookings
- Subway access varies; the 6 train serves Midtown East, the B and D lines reach Fordham
- Expect higher prices during playoff games, with some bars adding cover charges or drink minimums
Why Cleveland Loyalty Persists in New York
The psychology of these bars reveals something about urban identity and the limits of hometown pride. New York absorbs transplants from every state, but not every transplant assimilates. Cleveland natives, shaped by decades of sports heartbreak and Rust Belt resilience, carry their allegiances like heirlooms. They gather in basement taverns and pierogi rooms not just to watch basketball but to preserve a sense of place in a city that relentlessly erases the past. The Cavaliers become a proxy for something larger: a refusal to blend in, a middle finger to the assumption that New York fandom is inevitable.
The second round series against the Knicks intensifies this dynamic. Every Cleveland basket in a Manhattan bar is a small act of defiance, every wine-and-gold jersey a declaration of independence. The bars themselves become stages for a deeper cultural negotiation, where Midwestern stubbornness meets New York swagger and neither side blinks. It is theater and tribalism, commerce and community, all playing out over cheap beer and expensive rent. When the series ends, the bars will return to their regular rhythms, but the memory of those nights, the roar of a Cleveland crowd in the heart of Knicks country, will linger like a ghost in the neon glow.
Sources consulted: NBA Official Site · NYC Official Guide · MTA Subway Information · Eater New York · Time Out New York
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
