Start at Columbus Circle Because the Subway From Here Is the Worst Option
Columbus Circle at 59th and Broadway is the point where Broadway, Eighth Avenue, Central Park South, and Central Park West intersect at a single rotary built around the 1892 Christopher Columbus monument. The 1/A/B/C/D trains all stop here. So does the M5, M7, M10, M20, M104. Every subway and bus from the Upper West Side dumps you within ninety seconds of the circle.
Which is exactly why everyone takes the train one stop further to 50th Street or Penn Station, gets compressed into a peak-hour playoff-night car, and arrives at MSG already in a bad mood. The walking solution is to bail at Columbus Circle and travel the remaining 33 blocks on your own legs.
Two miles, 35 minutes at a normal pace, straight south down Broadway. You will not get lost. Broadway is a continuous diagonal artery from 59th to 34th and the entrance you want at MSG is on Seventh and 33rd, which is where Broadway naturally puts you.
The 6:25pm Start, the Real Reason
Tip-off for a Knicks playoff home game is 7:00pm or 7:30pm depending on the network. Doors at MSG open 90 minutes before tip-off, which means the building has been ingesting people since 5:30pm. The dangerous compression windows are not the doors — the doors are fine — but the surface streets and subway stations within four blocks of the Garden between 6:30pm and 6:55pm. That is the wave you are trying to walk in front of, not behind.
If you leave Columbus Circle at 6:25pm walking at a brisk 4 mph, you arrive at the Seventh and 33rd plaza at 7:00pm. You miss the surge by walking through it at right angles. The wave is moving east-west out of the subway. You are moving north-south down Broadway. The geometries do not collide.
Block by Block, What You Pass
- 59th to 56th — the south edge of Central Park is on your left. Columbus statue receding behind you. The Trump International Hotel pylon on the right.
- 56th to 50th — Hearst Tower at 57th and 8th visible to your right. The Time Warner / Deutsche Bank tower above you. Office workers emptying out of CBS at 51st.
- 50th to 45th — the Ed Sullivan Theater on the right at 53rd. The Brill Building at 49th. Eighth Avenue and Broadway are about to converge.
- 45th to 42nd — you are now inside Times Square. Walk in the Broadway pedestrian zone — the closed-to-traffic plazas that begin at 47th. The red bleachers at TKTS are at 47th. Eight minutes through the bowl of light.
- 42nd to 38th — Broadway leaves the pedestrian zone, becomes a normal northbound-and-southbound street. Bryant Park is one block east. Times Square is behind you.
- 38th to 34th — Herald Square. Macy's on your right. The triangle plaza in front of Macy's is a useful breather stop for two minutes.
- 34th to 33rd — you cross 34th. Penn Station is one block ahead. MSG sits on top of Penn Station. The Seventh Avenue Plaza entrance to MSG is on your right.
What This Walk Does That a Cab Does Not
A cab from the Upper West Side to MSG on a playoff night is $30 to $50 depending on surge and routes you down Eighth Avenue, which is gridlocked between 50th and 34th from 6:00pm. The driver will drop you on the wrong side of Eighth at the corner of a one-way and you will still walk three blocks. You will have paid forty dollars for the privilege of being five minutes late and irritable.
The walk is free, on time, and gives you 35 minutes of weather, light, and pre-game adrenaline that the cab will not. The Broadway route specifically routes you through the brightest pedestrian theater in North America in late golden hour. By the time you turn east on 33rd you are in the mental state the building is built to receive.
Game-Night Etiquette on the Walk
You will see at least eighty other people doing the same walk in orange and blue. The unspoken protocol is single-file in the pedestrian narrow stretches between 50th and 45th, no music out loud, no stopping for selfies in the middle of the sidewalk in Times Square, and no walking three-abreast past 38th when the sidewalk narrows. The walk works only if everyone keeps moving. The few people who do not understand this are the same people who block the subway doors.
You are not in a hurry. You are in a current. The current moves at 4 mph. Stay in it.
The Last Two Blocks Specifically
At 34th and Broadway you turn east and walk one block to Seventh. At Seventh you turn south and walk one block to 33rd. The Seventh Avenue Plaza entrance to MSG is on the southwest corner. The plaza is open-air, has bag-check tents in May, and runs north-south along the building's west face. Find your section number on your ticket. The 200-level plaza enters here. The 100-level enters through a different door on Eighth, and the suite level enters through the All Access entrance on 31st.
Bag check is real. Anything bigger than 14 by 14 by 6 inches is going home in a Lyft. The MSG bag policy on playoff nights is enforced harder than regular season.
After the Game, the Same Trick in Reverse
Game ends at roughly 9:45pm for a 7:30pm tip-off, or 9:15pm for a 7:00pm. The 19,500-seat building empties in 25 minutes through the same Penn Station ingestion the subway is built to handle but always sort of cannot. Walking back north on Broadway in reverse, you clear the crowd density inside three blocks, and by 38th you have the sidewalks to yourself again. Reverse the walk to Columbus Circle, 35 minutes, arrive 10:25pm. Tube home from there.
Or if you want a different ending: turn east at 34th and walk five blocks to the K-Town strip at 32nd Street between 5th and Madison. Korean barbecue runs until 2am. Knicks fans in orange and the Korean grandmother grilling beef do not interfere with each other in any direction.
The Practical Window
- Distance: 2.0 miles from Columbus Circle (59th and Broadway) to MSG Seventh Avenue Plaza (33rd and 7th).
- Time: 35 minutes at a brisk pace. Add 5 minutes if you stop at Macy's plaza.
- Best start: 6:25pm for a 7pm tip-off. 6:55pm for a 7:30pm tip-off.
- Tickets: the walk is free; the game is whatever StubHub says today.
- Getting there: 1/A/B/C/D to 59 St Columbus Circle. Or M104 bus down Broadway.
- Getting back: reverse walk to Columbus Circle. Or 1/2/3 train two stops from Penn to Columbus.
- Bag policy: 14 x 14 x 6 inches max. Anything larger gets you turned away at Seventh Plaza.
- Weather: this walk falls apart in heavy rain. Keep the cab as a real backup.
Why This Walk During Knicks Playoffs
Playoff games happen on a tight calendar — six games maximum per series — and the New York attention economy collapses around each one. Madison Square Garden in May is the loudest building in the United States. The Knicks have not been this deep in a postseason in a quarter century. The search trend, the orange-and-blue sidewalks, the OG Anunoby jerseys at every bar — this is the city in a specific mood, and that mood lasts only as long as the run lasts. Three weeks, maximum.
The walk down Broadway is the part of game night that does not require a ticket, a sponsorship, or a press pass. It is free, it is twenty thousand other fans wide, and it routes you through the brightest two miles of city this month is going to give you. The route is built into the geometry of Manhattan. You only need to recognize it.
Right on time, from 59th to 33rd, four mph, every playoff home game.
Tags: #knicks #knicksplayoffs #madisonsquaregarden #msg #broadwaywalk #thelongwayhome #karpofinds #nycwalks #columbuscircle #timessquare #heraldsquare #nbaplayoffs
Sources consulted: Madison Square Garden · NBA Knicks · MTA NYC Subway
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
