New York City fans searching charlotte vs pumas unam on Wednesday, August 5, should treat this as a watch-plan problem, not a same-day kickoff alert. Charlotte FC’s official Leagues Cup listing put Pumas UNAM at Bank of America Stadium on Tuesday, August 4 at 8:00 p.m. ET, and Charlotte’s site now points to recap and watch coverage. For a visiting supporter landing at Penn Station, the practical move is to use Midtown’s rail hub as the meeting point, confirm Smithfield Hall’s current football schedule, then choose between a short Chelsea walk, a subway hop, or a Penn-adjacent backup if weather, crowding, or timing gets messy.
Want the least fussy Midtown route and a backup bar before you move? Text Karpo for Penn Station-to-Smithfield guidance tied to today’s NYC transit and match-viewing context.
Penn Station Exit Choice for West 25th Street
Start by deciding whether your group is actually inside Penn Station or across Eighth Avenue at Moynihan Train Hall. Moynihan’s own guidance places the hall between Eighth and Ninth Avenues and 31st to 33rd Streets, directly across from Penn Station. Smithfield Hall lists its address as 138 West 25th Street, so your route is mainly a southbound Midtown walk with one final adjustment east or west depending on your exit.
For most visiting fans, the cleanest meetup is outside the fare area, after everyone has surfaced and checked messages. Penn can split groups across Seventh Avenue, Eighth Avenue, Long Island Rail Road, NJ Transit, Amtrak, and subway corridors. If one person exits at Moynihan and another at the Seventh Avenue subway side, do not improvise block by block. Pick one visible corner, regroup there, then move toward West 25th Street together.
Moynihan Train Hall as the Rail Buffer
Moynihan is useful when your supporter group includes Amtrak or LIRR riders who need restrooms, charging, or a calmer arrival point before a warm evening walk. The hall’s public hours are listed as 5:00 a.m. to 1:00 a.m. daily, with overnight Amtrak and LIRR activity shifting to Penn Station. That matters if post-match plans run late or someone is catching a train after the bar.
The tradeoff is that Moynihan is west of the ideal walking line to Smithfield Hall. It feels easier for arrivals, but it can add a little sideways movement if others are already near Seventh Avenue. Accessibility is the stronger reason to use it: Moynihan lists multiple entrances, public facilities, staff presence, and connections to Penn Station services. If anyone needs step-free routing, verify the exact elevator path before leaving the hall.
Smithfield Hall on West 25th Street
Smithfield Hall’s official site identifies it as a football-focused venue at 138 West 25th Street, New York, NY 10001, with a football schedule section and direct contact details. That makes it a logical Chelsea destination for soccer fans coming from Penn, but it does not mean every replay, post-match show, or requested feed is guaranteed. Call or check the venue’s live channels before committing a group tab.
Audience fit is the main advantage. A supporter group will usually prefer a room that expects football noise, scarves, split loyalties, and people arriving around screens instead of a generic happy-hour crowd. The failure mode is capacity or programming: if another fixture, private event, or sound policy takes priority, your easy outing becomes a sidewalk negotiation. Keep the venue’s phone number handy and confirm the match context before everyone starts walking.
Seventh Avenue Walk in a Warm Evening
If the weather is only warm and dry, walking from the Penn area is the simplest plan. From the Seventh Avenue side, move south toward West 25th Street, then cut toward Smithfield Hall’s block. It keeps the group above ground, avoids short subway waits, and lets late arrivals text their exact cross street. Build in extra patience around Madison Square Garden, hotel entrances, and evening commuter foot traffic.
The drawback is comfort. Warm evenings turn short Midtown walks into slow ones when people are carrying bags, wearing jerseys, or moving as a large group. If thunderstorms, heavy rain, or poor air quality appear in the forecast, do not make the walk the identity of the plan. Switch to a subway, taxi, or Penn-adjacent venue. The best route is the one that keeps the group intact and on time.
A C E or 1 2 3 Subway Backup
Moynihan’s guidance points to A, C, E and 1, 2, 3 subway access at 34th Street-Penn Station, with Herald Square also listed as an additional nearby connection. For this particular trip, the subway is not about saving a dramatic amount of distance. It is a weather and mobility backup when walking south through Midtown feels unpleasant, crowded, or too slow for someone in the group.
Before entering the fare area, check MTA service status for the exact lines you plan to use. Short subway trips can become inefficient when an entrance is closed, a downtown platform requires a detour, or service is rerouted. If the train choice is unclear, stay above ground and use a rideshare or taxi from the Penn or Moynihan pickup zones. Do not split the group across different lines unless everyone has the destination pinned.
The Irish Exit Inside Moynihan Train Hall
If Smithfield Hall cannot confirm the feed, or if trains arrive late, The Irish Exit at Moynihan Train Hall is a practical holding point because its official site places it at 421 Eighth Avenue. The venue lists Tuesday through Saturday hours as 10:00 a.m. to 12:00 a.m., with walk-ins welcome and bookings available for small groups. Treat it as delay insurance, not a guaranteed soccer-screen substitute.
This backup works best for mixed groups where some people are still arriving by Amtrak, LIRR, or subway. It reduces the risk of dragging luggage through Chelsea before the plan is settled. The tradeoff is atmosphere: a station pub may suit a waiting room decision better than a committed supporter watch. If the game feed, sound, or seating matters, ask directly before ordering and be ready to continue south.
Phone Call, Apple TV Check, and Group Text
The final action is simple: verify three things in this order before leaving Penn Station. First, confirm Smithfield Hall is showing the Charlotte-Pumas content you want, whether live archive, replay, highlights, or related coverage. Second, check MTA and rail status for the route home. Third, send one group text with the destination address, chosen exit, backup venue, and latest-arrival time for everyone.
That verification is especially important on Wednesday, August 5, because the confirmed Charlotte FC listing placed the match on Tuesday, August 4 at 8:00 p.m. ET, while Apple says Leagues Cup is available live and on demand through Apple TV. If the bar cannot confirm programming, make the evening a post-match meetup near Penn instead of a failed watch party. The easy plan is the one confirmed before motion.
Tags: #AskKarpo #BeforeYouGo #NYC #NewYorkCity #PennStation #MoynihanTrainHall #SmithfieldHall #ChelseaNYC #MidtownNYC #SoccerBar #LeaguesCup #CharlotteFC #PumasUNAM #TransitPlan
Sources consulted: Source 1: charlottefootballclub.com · Source 2: smithfieldnyc.com · Source 3: moynihantrainhall.nyc · Source 4: moynihantrainhall.nyc · Source 5: irishexit.com · Source 6: tv.apple.com
All trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
Ask Karpo first
Tell Karpo your date, group size, budget, and starting point. We’ll check current access, timing, transit, and the cleanest New York City plan for Smithfield Hall before you head out.
